If a question is downvoted on !nostupidquestions, is the question too stupid or was it not stupid enough?

shootwhatsmyname@lemm.ee to No Stupid Questions@lemmy.world – 284 points –
85

You are viewing a single comment

A similar problem would happen on r/ELI5 that drove me nuts. Originally the kinds of questions you were supposed to ask were things like “the origins of the Gulf war” or “the rules on how to play poker”. But instead there were too many questions that were like “what’s going on in my stomach when it growls”.

"Can someone explain [complicated geopolitical conflict] to me like I'm 5?" were my least favorite. At least pretend you tried to get the answer yourself

There should be a rule where someone actually has to explain it as if they were explaining it to a 5-year-old.

That's how the sub started. Answers were broken down into the most basic of analogies, it was great. But like most big subs, the rules got lax and it lost what made it special.

In my opinion, stricter posting rules make for a better community...as long as they're not arbitrary.

That might not be the best counter example. Now I'm interested in why exactly my stomach growls, and would probably need it explained in simple terms since I'm not a doctor.