Dear Lemmings, what is your personal approach to human diet?

BigBlackCockroach@lemmy.world to Ask Lemmy@lemmy.world – 73 points –

I know there are a lot of fad diets and then there is calorie counting as a more science based approach. I myself do calorie counting and follow a strict diet in order to avoid overeating. How do you eat all day, you follow a system?

95

You are viewing a single comment

I eat oats too, have you heard of the rumor that oats bind vitamins/minerals and thus you eat a a healthy breakfast with oats and fruit but the oats suck up all the nutrients and you get nothing out of it? I am not sure why but i think they claimed there was some binding agent in oats, like some chemical compound.

You're probably thinking of phytic acid. While it is present in raw oats, cooking it breaks it down. Most oats you buy from the store have been steamed, so it's even already cooked before you do anything with it. Cooking breaks down a lot of these types of compounds.

Can you find that claim in a reputable scientific study or at least a reputable journal (not an anti-carb paleo or keto blog)? I'd like to know more, but I can't find anything that isn't woo science.

While they contain phytic acid, I don't know if they contain enough quantity to counteract all the veggie/fruit nutrients you eat with it.

That article indicates that isolated phytates resulted in reduced absorption of calcium, iron, and zinc, but no significant effect was found when consumed in a matrix. Furthermore, phytate-containing grains tended to contain other compounds such as fermentable fiber that increased the bioavailability of those minerals, resulting in very little effect. So if that's the only evidence we have to go by, it doesn't sound like oatmeal is going to prevent you from absorbing the nutrients from fruits and veggies you eat with it, nor does if have any affect on the other nutritional benefits derived from oats.

I am not sure what evidence there is or what studies were the basis of the rumors I've heard, this study was what I found on google 😂