Should I use Matrix for Messaging?

Zerlyna@lemmy.world to No Stupid Questions@lemmy.world – 66 points –

I use an iPhone and my fiancé uses Android. He is not very tech savvy. He does not like to text for privacy reasons. I was going to recommend we get Signal but see others in Lemmy talking about Matrix. Is that better? If so, what app is best that works on both our phones? Thanks Lemmy friends!

43

You are viewing a single comment

Signal is great for one on one conversations or small groups. Matrix is better served for communities as federation offers censorship resitance, but they collect some metadata that Signal doesn't. They do have encrypted DMs, but it's less user friendly than Signal and if your partner is not tech savvy, I would go with Signal.

Signal has 2 points of concern:

  • Phone number requirement
  • Centralized server (one point of failure)

I use both for different groups of people. E.g. My Matrix account is publically listed on my Lemmy account, but my Signal one is only given to people I trust to some level.

Phone number requirement is disappearing, username accounts are coming soon

I don't think their are removing phone requirement, they will just add username support on top of it, so you can invite people using username, but still need phone to register an account.