Do you support sending weapons to Israel?

mozz@mbin.grits.dev to Ask Lemmy@lemmy.world – -38 points –

Humor me for a second. Quick poll. You can just write "Yes" or "No" in the comments.

59

You are viewing a single comment

I'm not angry at you or anything like that. I'm being super hostile partly just because I can be a dick in general, but also because it seems like you're being dishonest. If I've read it wrong then I apologize, but the type of thing you're saying just doesn't make sense to me.

It's just not that complex. I'll speak for myself: I didn't vote for Biden in the primary. I sort of expected him to be the exact type of establishment criminal that his background as a rich white guy who's worked in Washington all his life would suggest. Then he started doing good things for the working class and on climate change and I was surprised about it and for the first time decided he might be a good thing (instead of just not the end of the world like Trump would be). Then he started being okay with Israel slaughtering brown people and I stopped supporting him nearly as wholeheartedly -- like yes, he's returning to type as a war criminal like most US leaders; it's still better to vote for him instead of Trump, but also we should be working to build organizations that can replace him with something much much better. I don't think he started the war in Gaza, but he's certainly not doing the Palestinians any favors by enabling Netanyahu to do more or less whatever he wants.

I don't get where you arrived at this burning desire to decide that there are American Democrats who want to see Palestinians getting slaughtered in the streets by the thousands. I think population A hates it and opposes Biden on it, to this on-the-news-all-the-time-because-the-campus-or-the-person-is-on-fire extent, because he's enabling it. (While, maybe, still acknowledging that he's 10 times better than Trump by any standard.) I think another population B gets their news from establishment sources that don't really tell them that that's happening, that tell them that Israel is defending themselves from a terrorist attack and fighting a conventional war against armed opponents. I don't think that's what's happening, but I think they think that's what's happening, because the news is lying to them. And so they're okay with it. I don't think there's some population C that is both Democratic voters and understands what's going on and wants Israel to be doing what they're doing.

That's it. It's not complicated. It's not like some thing where you have to move the goalposts around in this convoluted manner to construct a person who voted for Biden in the primary because they want to murder Palestinians and they had a premonition that Hamas would attack Israel and Netanyahu would decide to start murdering the whole country and Biden loves all of that happening and so that's why they voted for Biden. The whole thing is cockamamie.

If I've misunderstood anything about what you're claiming happened then feel free to enlighten me. But you kept saying that people on Lemmy are okay with killing Palestinians, which I absolutely know isn't true, and the whole thing about the primary that you're saying now instead, makes so little sense that it's hard for me to take it seriously as a thing you actually believe. Sorry. If I'm a dick to you (which, maybe I shouldn't be), that is why.

But you kept saying that people on Lemmy are okay with killing Palestinians, which I absolutely know isn’t true

Okay let me be absolutely clear here, I know full well that Lemmy and even Reddit leans farther left. I'm not gonna argue with you that I gave you that impression. I'm just going to say here and now, I don't think the majority of Lemmy are in support of sending weapons to Israel. Hell I can hardly find anyone who admits to voting for Joe Biden in the 2020 primaries on here.

There are some and I set about finding those examples and even shared a few with you. If they exist here of all places then I speculate (I'm not trying to make some scientific claim here) there are a good number of them.

Hell I can hardly find anyone who admits to voting for Joe Biden in the 2020 primaries on here.

Dude why are you so hell bent on the 2020 primaries?

If they exist here of all places then I speculate (I'm not trying to make some scientific claim here) there are a good number of them.

Yeah probably so, I can agree with that. Looks to me like about 38% of Democrats support Israel more than Palestine. To me it's absolutely crazy that it's that high, but I think (for no particular reason) that that's a product of how bad the news coverage is, and how much it goes out of its way to present the situation with this criminally pro-Israel spin.

I think if they fully understood the situation they'd be on Team Palestine and the big changes lately have been mostly due to them understanding it more and more, as the "war" continues and what's happening gets more and more obvious and harder to justify, so there's this new narrative being presented that wasn't in the mainstream news before. But I have no real reason for thinking that, it's just my guesswork about what's going on. It'd be interesting to find a poll that was analyzing how people understand the situation and what they think is going on, not just asking about the final bottom-line answer they're coming up with.

Dude why are you so hell bent on the 2020 primaries?

Why aren't you? Would you like to be able to vote for a better candidate than Biden in the presidential general election? I would. That requires examining what happened in the primaries to figure out what can be changed.

What a fascinatingly straightforward, natural, and organic train of logic.

I can't tell if you're being sarcastic or not.

I am.

I had just reached the conclusion that maybe it was hasty to decide you're a troll. IDK, it's hard to tell these things over the internet.

Deciding whether or not to vote for Joe Biden should be based on analyzing what he's done in the time he's in office. Going back 4 years before he was in power, trying to get in the heads of the people that were voting for him even though there's no possible way to do that, and then trying to draw a conclusion from that that would inform in any way the decision about what to do in this general election, is totally bizarre bordering on unhinged. I think you are doing it on purpose to distract from the straight concept of "what will Biden probably do, what will Trump probably do, and which one do I want" (the answer to which is pretty clear after like 5-10 seconds of thought... which is why I suspect you're trying so hard not to analyze in those terms, because to you the "right answer" is not-Biden.)

Hope you're being paid well, at least. It can't be a super fun job.

Dude what the fuck is wrong with you? Do you have brain damage? You completely misunderstood my comment, assumed the worst and went right back to accusing me of being a troll.

Your reading comprehension is absolute trash and which would be fine except you have zero self awareness of it and just talk trash immediately.

Be better. But in the mean time go fuck yourself. Jesus Christ what a miserable person you are.

Yeah, I sure jumped to conclusions here. I didn't even talk to you at length and hear you out and explain what I was thinking, or give you a chance to respond. Must just suck as a person, I guess.