Is Google Maps getting worse?

hperrin@lemmy.world to Asklemmy@lemmy.ml – 266 points –

My dad uses Google Maps, and he mentioned that it seems to be getting worse. Like, giving him directions that are obviously worse than alternatives. Has anyone else here experienced this?

148

You are viewing a single comment

I've seen it do that for decades now, and in at least two cases I see it happen is when a highway enters town and gains a name, like how Florida Route 92 becomes International Speedway Boulevard when you enter Daytona Beach. Or, when another route joins the corridor you're on, like throughout North Carolina US-1, US-15 and US-501 weave in and out of each other a few times along with a few state routes joining and leaving.

So I think when it hits points like this, it sometimes interprets them as intersections rather than junctions, and its programming requires it to issue a direction for an intersection. YOU might not see it as an intersection but IT does.

I don’t need any instructions at all at an intersection unless the instruction is to turn

Thank you. I'm not actually that old-school, but back in the day, the only directions that mattered were the changes. "Turn right on the dirt road, and follow it for about 35 miles. Turn right at the crazy magenta and black diner..."

That's exactly what it is. I just had this happen where two US highways merge, and it told me to "keep straight on HWY 20" at that location. You'll also often see this where two interstates merge for a while in and around cities.

A bigger problem I have than occasionally hearing "Keep straight on Highway 20" is "Keep straight on US-20, US-94, US-1, US-15, US-501, US-99, US-98, NC-24, NC-27, NC-17, PG-13, PS-5, N-64, I-95, I-85, I-40, Bragg Boulevard for 1.3 miles."

It puts the instruction at the beginning, and then it talks so long you forgot what it told you to do. It's how you stack overflow a human.

I'm sorry, I wasn't paying attention. What were you saying?