LLMs like ChatGPT are not intelligent. They're just regurgitating information, making them susceptible to spreading misinformation like a fake moonlanding.

smegforbrains@lemmy.ml to Technology@lemmy.ml – 6 points –

TL;DR: LLMs are just mimicking natural language and conversation. Fact checking and healthy skepticism is not part of their model. For example they can be easily tricked into advocating conspiracy theories, like a fake moon landing. Google Bard is even stating arithmetic falsehoods like 5*6 != 30

3

The only use so far with any value (moral or factual) seems to be insane entertainment. I can't stop having a chuckle of the Harry Squatter videos and interactions people have with Neuro-sama.

I think trying to use this for anything even remotely factual is just asking for a paddlin'.

It's the inability of LLMs to do maths which really ought to give some of its more naive proponents pause for thought. It can't do what a pocket calculator could do 50 years ago. It can't do what an abacus could do centuries ago. How is anyone still taking this cheap expensive magic trick so seriously?

not sure what you're saying here. are you claiming it can't do any sort of reasoning or open-ended problem solving?

i think we're fairly confident now that they can do structured reasoning to some degree. it is not flawless in that it might not give you real or accurate information every time, but we are also figuring out the contexts behind that. as for spreading misinformation, anything intentional prompted to be incorrect is irrelevant to gauging intelligence. unintentional results don't necessarily mean it's unintelligent either.

there's a really good document on this aspect as well.

https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/D7PumeYTDPfBTp3i7/the-waluigi-effect-mega-post

there are a lot of ethical and technical aspects of LLMs that are severely underdeveloped, but that shouldn't be a surprise to anyone. i don't think any of that would suggest that it's reasonable to disregard the absurd pace of development this past decade, and last few years especially. good thing we have a sudden surge of attention towards developing these things.