South Korea court orders Japan to compensate 'comfort women', reverses earlier ruling

Salamendacious@lemmy.world to News@lemmy.world – 185 points – South Korea court orders Japan to compensate 'comfort women', reverses earlier ruling
reuters.com

SEOUL, Nov 23 (Reuters) - A South Korean appellate court on Thursday ordered Japan to compensate a group of 16 women who were forced to work in Japanese wartime brothels, overturning a lower court ruling that dismissed the case and prompting a stern protest from Tokyo.

63

You are viewing a single comment
View all commentsShow the parent comment

Why do you want the source (?) of my nationality rather than that of my arguments?

I mean, by questioning my nationality you basically told me I was lying about my nationality. And, you say that wasn't going to upset me? It makes no sense.

And how am I supposed to prove my nationality? Was I expected to be stupid enough to upload my passport? But even then, how would you verify that's actually my passport?

I don't know how anyone can expect otherwise, but it's only natural for the conversation to go hostile, whatever excuse you make with after the fact.

Yes I'm angry. But anyone'd imagine you write your comment differently if you didn't want to anger me...

I care if someone is suggesting they know more than they do by lying about where they’re from.

I don’t care what your passport says, if you’ve been there long enough to know what’s actually going on. Since your understanding comes from living there, it is the source of your argument.

That’s why I said I expected you to answer in Japanese slang.

But yeah, I do assume people on the internet are lying, I thought that was normal. I don’t eat angry when people doubt my statements online, as long as they’re not spreading disinformation while doing it. I assume we all have a blank slate online.

I’m sorry I phrased my doubt in a way that angered you- that really wasn’t my intention. It seems you doubt me there, but I similarly have no way to prove that.

I think we’re at an impasse on this.

For your convenience, I should have put these from the beginning.

English source:

Government denies that "comfort women" were coerced by the Japanese military.

A scholarly article
explaining how Shinzo Abe's government denied coercion in 2007.

Here's the formal Japanese record from the congress.

I appreciate the work. I know that the government of Japan has not addressed its role in the war well. I just wanted to know if the two people talking about their perspectives as Japanese people (regardless of nationality) were actually speaking from experience or not.

If your perspective is based solely on government action, that’s entirely fair (though not what I expected). I’m American born, but live in Germany and am in the naturalization process here (perhaps why nationality isn’t important to me- people whose families have been living in Germany for four plus decades are frequently not citizens), so I understand shame in your government’s actions, specifically to the degree that the governmental position is more important than the general public opinion (a typical American would probably not have an opinion towards American interaction in the Philippines, for example, so the government position is the only relevant one).

In that case though, I agree that it’s irrelevant that you’re Japanese, as you’re forming your opinion not on your experience with Japanese people, but on official government documents.