MDN can now automatically lie to people seeking technical information · Issue #9208 · mdn/yari | MDN now providing LLM generated explainer text for code samples

farcical_continuation@programming.dev to Programming@programming.dev – 3 points –
MDN can now automatically lie to people seeking technical information · Issue #9208 · mdn/yari
github.com

Seems pretty bad?

9

You are viewing a single comment

This feature is in beta. That issue title is sort of exaggerated tbh. Test it if you want, but take everything their beta LLM spits out with grain of salt.

I suppose they can add source URL of information, so, you can verify correctness. But then I don't get it why we need lying AI if we can get URL in the first place. So, it will work just like any other good search engine.

Sorry if I sound salty, but I still don't get why companies put fake AI engines everywhere.

The "ai explain" button doesn't mention that it's in beta even in the expanded detail text. But more importantly, even once out of beta, LLMs will never be trustworthy references without humans vetting them. This isn't a "beta" problem it's a "completely misunderstood the problem and solution" problem.

It's crazy how this technology that does nothing more than automatically generate text similar to text humans would write (or whatever else it's trained on) has so many people convinced it's a source of expertise on everything.

There's nothing in there with a capacity of reasoning or awareness of fact. It's the difference between an ALU and a CPU at this point. And a lot of people perfectly aware of that fact are essentially grifting the less savvy masses who see a black box that sounds smart.

It may do more harm than good, it spits plausible answers that are either completely or subtly wrong (latter is worse obviously) and it’s not easy to discern how good an answer actually is