Texas’ Border Stunt Is Based on the Same Legal Theory Confederate States Used to Secede

MicroWave@lemmy.world to politics @lemmy.world – 440 points –
Texas’ Border Stunt Is Based on the Same Legal Theory Confederate States Used to Secede
thedailybeast.com

A clash between Texas and the Biden administration over who controls the Texas-Mexico border continues to escalate this week as federal officials once again demanded the state give Border Patrol agents access to a park that is a popular corridor for migrants to enter the United States illegally.

This comes in response to a recent Supreme Court decision, where the court allowed federal officials to dismantle a wire barrier along the border, prompting a legal battle initiated by Texas. Texas argued that this action, aimed at aiding migrants, infringes on state sovereignty and damages Texas security measures.

In response to this decision, Texas Gov. Greg Abbott released a letter arguing that Texas has a right to control the border and that it supersedes federal government control. Abbott’s accusation that the federal government has breached the Constitution by having “broken the compact between the United States and the States” is almost identical to South Carolina’s 1860 declaration of secession.

Furthermore, Abbott’s letter espouses the fringe theory of constitutional law known as “compact theory,” popularized by Confederate states during the Civil War era and supported by Confederate President Jefferson Davis.

46

You are viewing a single comment

You really do not, here is why in no particular order:

  • When Texas does, other red states will follow.
  • Once that happens, forget human rights for anyone other than white men. Arrests/executions of trans folks, for example, will be a thing.
  • Blue folks in the red area will be trapped and unable to get back home.
  • War will break out, millions if lives will be lost.
  • Don’t count on the military. Much of it id in red states and many members of the military are republicans.

Less likely, but far worse scenario could happen in addition to the above: Russia, Iran, North Korea, China, and other countries take advantage and attack parts of europe and possibly parts of the US. The US is a large part of NATO, so NATO will struggle to respond to the combined threat.

I understand wanting to see it happen, but much of what I said is very likely to play out if TX follows through.

You don’t need to believe me, but just think it through.

Gotta disagree with the last two bullets. I think it's pretty unlikely any active duty military switches sides. So you're left with the largest military arsenal on the planet and one of the largest standing armies vs the Texas rangers, which likely would just haul ass to the US. I mean why wouldn't they? They don't have infinite weapons and personnel on their side.

They'd have it over in an afternoon if there was an armed conflict at all.

9 more...