Live updates: Iran’s retaliatory attack on Israel has begun

MagicShel@programming.dev to News@lemmy.world – 255 points –
Live updates: Iran’s retaliatory attack on Israel has begun
nbcnews.com
162

You are viewing a single comment

What about my statement do you disagree with?

While it is impossible to have an accurate count, the best estimates are that about 1/3 of those killed have been combatants. The UN estimates 90% civilian casualties across all wars. The Iraq war was similar in that it involved urban, embedded terror groups and modern technology. The civilian casualty ratio was 77%. This war is in line with other conflicts of the past 50 years.

It is still a terrible tragedy. War is always a tragedy.

50 years is a long time, improved technology should reduce civilian casualties not keep them in line.

Iraq was a military failure, Israel's assault on Gaza is a military failure, and the world needs to recognize it.

True. Unfortunately, I'm not sure that we have yet seen what a military success looks like in the Middle East.

Leaving the middle east, as politically caustic as the idea may be, its the only viable path to military success in the region.

The Iraq war was fought against a standing military. The follow-on counter insurgency was far less lethal to civilians. Call us when Hamas is running T-80 Tank Divisions.