If you are a Libertarian and hold liberty as your core value, why do you not believe in universal healthcare? Nothing impacts liberty more than sickness and death.

Camzing@lemmy.world to Ask Lemmy@lemmy.world – 348 points –
555

You are viewing a single comment

"Libertarian" became popular in the US when it started being incorporated into various science fiction novels. Probably the most famous is "The Moon Is A Harsh Mistress." I love the book as science fiction, but the society the author creates depends on so many caveats that even the author has the old style 'free' system fall apart as soon as an actual government [as opposed to prison regulations] is formed.

“Libertarian” became popular in the US when it started being incorporated into various science fiction novels.

They got their que from right-wing economic grifters like Rothbard and Hayek - people whose beliefs wouldn't be out of place in Nazi Germany. That's why olden days US sci-fi writing was a festering hole of fascism - nothing else could have produced people like Heinlein.

Heinlein was a huge friend to Philip K. Dick, and any number of Jewish science fiction writers. He was one of the first writers to have an African woman as a hero, one of the first to have a transman character. Stop using the word 'fascist' for anyone on the Right. It dilutes the term.

and any number of Jewish science fiction writers.

And?

He was one of the first writers to have an African woman

And?

one of the first to have a transman character.

Again... and?

Stop using the word ‘fascist’ for anyone on the Right. It dilutes the term.

All right-wingers walk the same path. If you write fascist drivel, you are a fascist. Heinlein was a fascist. Stop making excuses for him.

How many socialistic writers wrote sci-fi that included Africans and the TG?

Was it back when Stalin outlawed homosexuality and allying with Hitler?

Plenty.

Could you name me one?

let's say before 1950.

Then click the link.

Sorry about that: I didn't realize there was a link; and thanks for making it.

Neither the words "socialist" nor "leftist" appears in that article.

Neither the words “socialist” nor “leftist” appears in that article.

They don't have to because...

The title, Of One Blood, refers to the biological kinship of all human beings.

...sounds perfectly radical to me.

We have a biological kinship with all mammals.

You have to be more specific.

This is not to denigrate her work, and she might have had at least some sympathies with socialists and leftists, but it's probably neither socialist nor leftist in the same way that Rand was ideological, much less "Fascist."

6 more...
6 more...
6 more...
6 more...
6 more...
6 more...
6 more...
6 more...
6 more...
14 more...
14 more...

I got mine from the Libertarian party, a few decades ago.

They didn't seem too fascistic back then.

Of course they didn't, eh? Of course.

They didn't wear brown, black, or blue uniforms.

They wore no uniforms.

One seemed to like Dead Kennedy's and Black Flag.

They didn’t wear brown, black, or blue uniforms.

Most fascists don't.

One seemed to like Dead Kennedy’s and Black Flag.

And up until very recently a whole bunch of them thought Rage Against The Machine was theirs, too.

They seem most powerful in uniform—I guess that's what helps ties those little sticks together into their mighty hammer, FWIW.

I don't like Rage Against the Machine.

Part of it is musical, I suppose.

Part of it is they support tankies and a group that massacred indigenous peasants in Peru.

They seem most powerful in uniform

Sure. But it also makes knowing who to shoot a whole lot easier, too.

Part of it is they support tankies and a group that massacred indigenous peasants in Peru.

I'm not sure what RATM's deal with the (so-called) "Shining Path" lot was... there's nothing unique about leftists having shit takes or throwing their weight behind the wrong cause. It comes with the territory.

Yes, it does make fascists better targets.

RATM's previous support of Shining Path, or for that matter the USSR, would probably be quite forgivable if they admitted that they made mistakes—confessions, if you will.

Have they written anything about their beliefs, and explaining such, besides very generalized stuff like "fuck capitalism," "fuck imperialism," "fuck fascism," "fuck American foreign policy," "fuck this," "fuck that," whatever?

It's why I'm still ticked at Cat Stevens/Yusef Islam, and his endorsement of the attempted murder of Salman Rushdie, and his later denials of such.

14 more...
14 more...