1,000 Harvard Students Walk Out of Commencement to Support 13 Seniors Barred from Graduation over Gaza

IndustryStandard@lemmy.world to News@lemmy.world – 1102 points –
Students Walk Out of Harvard Commencement After 13 Barred from Graduation over Gaza
democracynow.org

More than a thousand Harvard students walked out of their commencement ceremony yesterday to support 13 undergraduates who were barred from graduating after they participated in the Gaza solidarity encampment in Harvard Yard.

Asmer Safi, one of the 13 pro-Palestinian student protesters barred from graduating, says that while his future has been thrown into uncertainty while he is on probation, he has no regrets about standing up for Palestinian rights.

147

You are viewing a single comment

Yes, an assumption you have no evidence to back up.

You think that because you personally haven't heard of something, HR people in major companies have never heard of it when the fact is, they're probably hiring people from all over the world and, because of that, have heard of one of the worlds most well-known and prestigious universities.

It's been around since the 13th century. It was the alma mater of Marie Curie and Simone de Beauvoir (perhaps you've also never heard of them). According to Wikipedia, its scientists have won 33 Nobel prizes and 6 Fields medals.

So basically you're saying that HR people in major companies don't understand how to do their jobs because of something you personally have never heard of.

I'm just going to continue this conversation quoting myself from here on out, because you're literally making arguments I've already directly addressed.

These aren’t things universally judged by HR managers who, making the assumption they’re even good at their job, might recognize elite foreign institutions, they’re judged by everyday people who might not even be able to name the full top 10 US-based universities, but know the name “Harvard”.

Yes, and I'm going to keep repeating this: Just because you haven't heard of it doesn't mean other people haven't heard of it.

Ok, why do you think HR managers are the only people who matter for a prestigious university degree? Or that some people also recognizing it would mean it was a functional replacement for somewhere nearly all people recognize? You've just never even addressed anything I've written, even when I quote it back a second time.

Why do you think that you're not an outlier when it comes to recognizing, again, one of the most prestigious universities in the world which is responsible for dozens of Nobel prizes?

Again, answer my questions. I've humored you long enough for someone unwilling to address the text I've written.

Okay, to answer your questions:

Ok, why do you think HR managers are the only people who matter for a prestigious university degree?

I don't. I think most people have heard of La Sorbonne. You just hadn't.

Or that some people also recognizing it would mean it was a functional replacement for somewhere nearly all people recognize?

I don't. I think most people have heard of La Sorbonne. You just hadn't.

Please apply that answer to all of your other questions too.

Ok, this is just disconnected from reality. Most people in the US haven't heard of Caltech, let alone a foreign university. Maybe Oxford, but that's not at all certain. The average person knows Harvard and MIT because they're in movies, whatever big school is closest to them, and a some sports schools.

Sorbonne is #48 in the US News global rankings. Pretty good! But well behind the weakly known Caltech (#9) or the top ranked Harvard (#1). The next highest rated US school above Sorbonne is the University of Pittsburgh. No one would ever say "just swap your Harvard degree for Pitt, it'll open similar doors". And this is on a list that's largely judged by people in academia who have a wide familiarity with schools. Ask a random American whether Utrecht University (#44) is a good school and they'll have no idea. They're unlikely to even known Utrecht is a city.

If you want to show me actual evidence to support your claim that most Americans haven't heard of it, go for it. Good luck.

Anyway, we're not talking about the average person. We're talking about the sort of person who hires Harvard graduates. If they don't know about really good universities in other countries, they really suck at their job when they're hiring people at the high end like that. So if you want to claim HR people who hire Harvard graduates suck at their jobs... well, good luck.

Holy fuck, no we're not. This will be the third time the second line saying such explicitly has passed before your eyes. People exploit degrees for things other than getting hired.

And it’s not just hiring where prestige can be useful, it’s business pitches, op-eds, political speaking. These aren’t things universally judged by HR managers who, making the assumption they’re even good at their job, might recognize elite foreign institutions, they’re judged by everyday people who might not even be able to name the full top 10 US-based universities, but know the name “Harvard”.

I'm done. You've repeatedly shown yourself to be unwilling to actually engage in anything I've written and have some odd fantasy about the notoriously well-informed American public.

Got it. You're making the "HR people suck at their jobs" argument.

And it’s not just hiring where prestige can be useful, it’s business pitches, op-eds, political speaking. These aren’t things universally judged by HR managers ... , they’re judged by everyday people who might not even be able to name the full top 10 US-based universities, but know the name “Harvard”.

I like how you keep leaving out the first part of that post as if you never said it.