Lemmy devs are considering making all votes public - have your say

Rimu@piefed.social to Fediverse@lemmy.world – 805 points –
github.com

Probably better to post in the github issue rather than replying here.

https://github.com/LemmyNet/lemmy/issues/4967

860

You are viewing a single comment

No, as it would create a lot of excuses for targeted harrassment and just increase toxicity

Excuses are only that, especially if your instance has already implemented robust server rules against harassment.

I think the real sign of toxicity is weighting (perceived) anonymity over accountability for your actions on any platform. I'll vote for transparency any day.

Accountability, really? Okay, what's your full legal name and address? If you're totally fine with your idea of accountability, why not tell us all?

Nice cherrypicking. Don't get a bellyache from that fine harvest.

Edit for context: as I wrote elsewhere, "Anybody using the fediverse is ensured pseudonymity already, the privacy issue should be whether your account(s) can be linked to your real life identity against your will."

I'm perfectly happy with being accountable for what I say and do within our pseudonymous community here. Our bad faith friend above doesn't get to pull his infantile whataboutism, sorries.

Nice dodging. Here's hoping you get doxxed someday, I think that would be hilarious.

the vote history of your lemmy account is visible

vs

your real name and address are exposed

how the fuck are these things similar

You mentioned accountability. Do you believe that only extends to an online profile?

You mentioned accountability

not really. but yes i believe your online profile, as vague as that term is, can and should remain distinct from your irl personal info. what your account has up or down voted on activitypub is a far cry from being personal info

(edited for clarity)

Can you see how easily one can use that logic to basically be as abusive as they want online and be A-OK with their online account being held accountable as long as it doesn't actually impact their personal life?

it's a bit slippery slopey but yes i suppose so. if your downvoting sprees amount to being abusive as the admins or mods define it then on their terms your account should be banned, ip banned, whatever. i don't think there's any voting based behaviour that gets you in irl trouble, obviously posts inciting violence, sending credible threats or other behaviour that gets you noticed by your regional authorities is another kettle of fish, but none of that seems relevant to up/downvotes being visible