The Incognito Mode Myth Has Fully Unraveled

jeffw@lemmy.world to Technology@lemmy.world – 385 points –
The Incognito Mode Myth Has Fully Unraveled
wired.com
80

You are viewing a single comment

What about it is ambiguous or not written for less tech savvy people?

You do know they updated it soon after this became a major thing, right?

That linked picture is at least from 2017 from a quick research. What they clarify now in the latest update is that Google is not exempt from tracking your activity.

I don't know that actually. I recall similar wording going back to when Incognito tabs were launched.

Got a source on that?

Google quietly updates Chrome’s incognito warning in wake of tracking lawsuit

[...]

Here’s the updated text (emphasis added):

“Others who use this device won’t see your activity, so you can browse more privately. This won’t change how data is collected by websites you visit and the services they use, including Google. Downloads, bookmarks and reading list items will be saved.

https://www.theverge.com/2024/1/16/24039883/google-incognito-mode-tracking-lawsuit-notice-change

The text in that article is different from your screenshot, I don't know what's up with that. Perhaps it's regional.

I believe the one I posted is older, based on the logo.

So looks like they've updated multiple times, each more reader-friendly than the last...

They might have changed the wording, but it's been insanely clear for many years, and it never at any point implied it changed anything about what websites did.

You and I may have known, but

it's been insanely clear for many years

If it had been clear it wouldn't have become an issue.

It isn't an issue. The exact wording might have changed, but the content has been identical for years and years. It included "sites and others who can see your traffic can do whatever the hell they want" the whole time, in entirely unambiguous idiot proof language.

This is an imaginary horseshit lawsuit. It was not possible to read the very obvious text and be misled about what incognito mode did or didn't do at any point, and it was automatically displayed in every tab. There was never at any point any possible room for confusion.

It is implied that google is not storing any tracking information...

If your employer, your ISP, and the websites you visit can see your browsing history, why is the implication that Google isn't storing tracking info?