In movies a strong woman is manly. (big muscles, aggressive, punches people, etc.) Is that really the way it is?

spiderwort@lemm.eebanned from sitebanned from site to No Stupid Questions@lemmy.world – -32 points –

To clarify : "strength of character"

61

You are viewing a single comment

And Ripley. Tall. Squarejawed. Ripped. Kicks ass constantly. Can drive a big robot loader thingy, to the impressment of the alpha dudes.

Can you think of any examples of movie portrayal of strong women that did not involve turning into a man?

Surely it exists.

Yeeeah, adding my voice to the "WTF you on about" choir, but since this is a fun exercise anyway: -10 Cloverfield Lane -The African Queen -The Apartment -As Good As It Gets -Bumblebee -Coraline -Dune -Fargo -Interstellar

Yeah, ok, look, I'm just looking at my DVD shelf and getting more confused about WTH you're talking about every couple of entries. This is a very weird hot take.

a woman can be physically strong without “turning into a man”.

strength of character? how about “nomadland” or “meek’s cutoff”?

I have not seen either of those.

But you see what I mean, right? A strong female character invariably starts looking like a man. Which is, of course, a cheap shortcut on the part of the writer.

What are feminine expressions of strength?

She doesn't look manly at all. What are you talking about?

It's like they took arnold schwartzenegger's jaw and transplanted it onto a supermodel/kickboxer.

musculature is not solely masculine, but if that’s the association for you, it makes sense that you feel a woman with muscles “starts looking like a man”. a similar circular reasoning would be arrived at if you simply considered strength itself to be a masculine trait.