'Bollard Man': Hero who confronted stabber promised Australia visa

Wilshire@lemmy.world to World News@lemmy.world – 188 points –
'Bollard Man': Hero who confronted stabber promised Australia visa
bbc.com
46

You are viewing a single comment

You don't need to be a psychologist to determine whether his mental illness was a factor.

I'm not saying his mental illness was the reason.

Please continue saying more contradictory statements.

If you think it could be a factor, then you think it might be a reason that he did this. It could be a factor, but again, neither of us are equipped to evaluate the mental status of someone based on news articles.

Edit: Factor =/= Reason. My argument in this message is flatly incorrect due to this, though I'll leave it up.

Factor and reason is not the same thing...

You know what, you're right. Looks like I've gone too long assuming they were interchangeably usable by changing the surrounding words.

I'll redact my previous statement, though to be clear, I still strongly disagree that one could say that the attackers schizophrenia was definitely a factor in this without having a previously existing mental evaluation and the expertise to understand it. You could say that it's more likely to have been influenced by his schizophrenia, but as I previously noted, a relatively small minority of schizophrenic people are violent (10-15%).

Fair enough! 🙂