Pro-Palestine demonstrators in Portugal assaulted by Israeli tourists

spirinolas@lemmy.world to World News@lemmy.world – 376 points –
Ativistas prĂ³-Palestina agredidas por turistas de Israel em Coimbra
www-jn-pt.translate.goog
77

You are viewing a single comment

And Germans have to take the responsibility for the atrocities of the Nazi time yes. What are you on about? If people vote for a government in a democratic election they bear responsibility for it. Not individually but as a people.

Also the Germans voted Hitler once and then there were no more elections. Israel had 11 elections since Netanyahu first came into power. And also the non Netanyahu governments continued the "settlements" aka ethnic cleansing of the West Bank.

To reiterate: We don't judge a people by their nation state. That's how atrocities get normalized.

Denying people tourist visas based on their country being complicit in a genocide is not an atrocity. Committing genocide is.

To reiterate: We don't judge a people by their nation state. That's how atrocities get normalized.

So by your logic Germany should not have paid reparations to the survivors and descendants of the Holocaust and should have paid no reparations to the countries it invaded? Because that was paid by the tax payer money of the people who were part of the war generation and the generations after. Even though clearly the generations after were not directly complicit, they bear the historic responsibility.

What you are advocating for under the guise of not "normalizing atrocities" is to simply abolish every people from being held accountable for their atrocities.

No I'm not. You're putting so, so many inaccurate words in my mouth. That's why I simply repeat myself so you can continue to play crazy person.

We don't judge the Russian people for Putin's actions.

We don't judge Germans for Hitler's actions.

People are people. Countries are countries.

To reiterate: We don't judge a people by their nation state. That's how atrocities get normalized.

We do judge those people who voted for Hitler. The Germans do so as well. We use that political party as a slur for a reason. I would not be surprised if other countries use "Nazi" as a slur as well.

Russia's election is a joke. That's what makes this different from blaming the Germans who voted for Hitler for giving the world Hitler.

Are you getting paid by Zionists to spam that thing about the nation state, it's really fucking weird

Why would you think I am a Zionist? jfc. You people are braindead.

You don't judge people based on where they're fucking born.

Do you know what "nation state" means? Apparently not.

Why'd you downvote me, I didn't ask what you were, I asked if they were paying you. Clearly your hands are running faster than your brain is.

I downvoted you because it's an asinine question.

1 more...
1 more...