Minecraft players outraged as Microsoft deletes accounts that weren't transitioned

nanoUFO@sh.itjust.worksmod to Games@sh.itjust.works – 339 points –
Minecraft players outraged as Microsoft deletes accounts that weren't transitioned
tomshardware.com
166

You are viewing a single comment

still sucks but I mean they did warn about this for propably over 2 years

i feel like it was longer. its been more than that since I last played minecraft and I definitely remember getting the warning multiple times via email I feel like it even got delayed based on how long ago it feels.

yeah now that I think about it it might be over 3 years :D proåably even more

Yeah seriously…. I received so fucking many emails over the last n years about it. I hadn’t touched mc in many years, pre MS acquisition and I was made well aware of what was happening.

There are comments in this thread talking about MS had taken purchases away, like come on now.

More like 5 years, my account was migrated in 2019 (found the email looking for something else) and I remember not doing it right away, but because I had already received multiple emails from them warning me about it.

Okay, but breach of contract isn't okay just because you announced you were going to do it well in advance. It just makes their culpability easier to prove because they announced their unlawful intentions extremely clearly.

I haven't read into this but do you have actual proof that it was unlawful in any way? this is no different from game servers and websites shutting down and it happens all the time

Well then read into it if you want to make pronouncements about it. It is the revocation of a license that was sold in perpetuity. That is quite different to no longer providing a service in general. It is selectively denying service to a certain group without legal cause. There were no terms in the contract with Mojang that they could unilaterally remove the license if you didn't do a specific digital dance on their terms. If it is unlawful, the lawsuit will determine that.

And my point is that if it is indeed unlawful, then telling people years in advance makes no difference, especially if, in some cases mentioned in this very thread, people tried to transfer and couldn't and were given no way to fix it.