'We Are All Culpable': Third American Self-Immolates to Protest Israel's Gaza Onslaught

return2ozma@lemmy.world to politics @lemmy.world – 373 points –
'We Are All Culpable': Matt Nelson Self-Immolates to Protest Israel's Gaza Onslaught | Common Dreams
commondreams.org
132

You are viewing a single comment

You really don't want to have policy be swayed by suicides.

Yes I do.

I don't care what method brings about the end of the genocide.

It encourages more people to kill themselves.

Yeah, if you stop a genocide thanks to people self immolating then people will start doing it to try and get weed legal next...

Yes I do.

Then you're letting sentiment drive you rather than reason.

And just to be really fucking clear: I'm against the genocide that is being inflicted on the people of Gaza. But I refuse to allow that someone's opinion should be given more weight than mine just because they mutilate or kill themselves. Their mental disorder doesn't confer moral superiority, it detracts from it.

Then you're letting sentiment drive you rather than reason.

So you wouldn't want the genocide to end if it came at the cost of someone killing themselves? Why?

Is the entire Palestinian population who are suffering a genocide worth less than a western life to you?

But I refuse to allow that someone's opinion should be given more weight than mine just because they mutilate or kill themselves.

His opinion holds more weight than yours because he is right and you are attacking a martyr rather than focusing on the cause he was martyrd for.

Their mental disorder doesn't confer moral superiority, it detracts from it.

Your insistence that they must be mentally ill/disorderd doesn't negate moral superiority, it only further reveals your apologist mindset.