Reminder that this is a thing that could happen.

Striker@lemmy.worldmod to Mildly Infuriating@lemmy.world – 559 points –
169

You are viewing a single comment

PeerTube needs more traction.

PLEASE - Just do anything to give Youtube a run for its money. They're steamrolling right now due to the promise of ad-revenue to streamers though. Idk how to fight that

How does PeerTube handle storage? I'm trying to imagine trying to create a federated system version of Youtube and it seems very problematic. Storage and bandwidth.

Quoting Wikipedia:

Each PeerTube instance provides a website to browse and watch videos, and is by default independent from others in terms of appearance, features and rules.

Several instances, with common rules (e.g. allowing for similar content, requiring registration) can form federations, where they follow one's videos, even though each video is stored only by the instance that published it. Federations are independent from each other and asymmetrical: one instance can follow another to display their videos without them having to do the same. Instances' administrators can each choose to mirror individual videos or whole friend instances, creating an incentive to build communities of shared bandwidth.

Videos are made available via HTTP to download, but playback favors a peer-to-peer playback using HLS and WebTorrent. Users connected to the platform act as relay points that send pieces of video to other users, lessening the bandwidth of each to the server and thus allowing smaller hardware to operate at a lower cost.

Wikipedia Source

Ah so the P2P works via instances, not users. Interesting idea.

sounds like Lemmy.

Yeah, but Lemmy instances don't split bandwidth P2P. Imagine hosting a video on some cheap cloud instance that doesn't have any kind of traffic sharing and putting some brand new game trailer up like Diablo 4, then someone links your video copy on something like Reddit. You'd get obliterated if all the video traffic was just coming from your server.

Peertube also uses ActivityPub, so theoretically, you can follow channels in Lemmy or Lemmy posts in PeerTube. Same with Mastodon. Not sure exactly how that works, though.

Kind of like how KBin also uses ActivityPub, so Lemmy users can use KBin magazines as if they were Lemmy communities.

Thanks! Peertube looks like the perfect foundation, at least for the current scale. You can post peertube urls in Mastodon or Lemmy and share the comment stream over the fediverse. We are in the earliest days right now, but it is on!

R.I.P Invidious. Good ol’ enshittification.

What happened to Invidious?

YouTube sent a cease and desist to TheFrenchGhosty, the project manager of Invidious.

However, he doesn't seem to care, because he doesn't see any legal merit in the letter.

Blog post
GitHub issue post

Damn, that's sad news. Thanks for the answer.
Edit : and for the links. His blog post was such a pleasure to read.

I think 2023-2024 is going to be the years of decentralization.

How does it monetize? What makes it attractive to creators?

I had the same questions. The first one is answered here better than I could.

As to monetization, I would think that that's up to the creator. The Patreon model, sponsors. Like that.