“MP3 is dead” missed the real, much better story. MP3 is supported by everything, everywhere, and is now patent-free.

☆ Yσɠƚԋσʂ ☆@lemmy.ml to Technology@lemmy.ml – 269 points –
marco.org
39

You are viewing a single comment

Not being encumbered by patents is a huge advantage for MP3s going forward, and the reality is that MP3 is good enough for vast majority of situations. The improvements newer formats like AAC bring are not worth the trouble of being chained to a proprietary format.

There's always Opus.

Sure, but is there any practical benefit using Opus given that MP3 is much more widely implemented?

Much better quality for the same bitrate and it's supported pretty much everywhere too.

I was a flac snob when I was younger, and I can say with certainty: 320kbps mp3s or even VBR are indistinguishable from opus or even lossless except when listening very very very closely on high end hardware. I'm very into audio still and production etc. That's not to say opus isn't better or higher quality, but the difference it makes is decidedly negligible to the vast majority of listeners. I guarantee that almost everyone would fail to do better than a coin flip a/b testing these technologies on the same audio recording.

192kbps opus will allow you to achieve roughly the same quality as 320kbps mp3. If you stream your music from any device or have a larger collection this difference can matter a lot.

1 more...

As a music producer, you notice 192k MP3. The next jumps you probably don't notice. I'm still a flac snob because I have to work a lot with original quality files, but for the average users there's probably not even a difference between MP3 192k+ and flac or wav or opus or whatever.

1 more...
1 more...
1 more...
1 more...
1 more...