Valve appear to be not willing to publish games with AI generated content

birlocke_@kbin.social to PC Gaming@kbin.social – 150 points –
reddit.adminforge.de

Valve quietly not publishing games that contain AI generated content if the submitters can't prove they own the rights to the assets the AI was trained on

105

You are viewing a single comment

If a human artist learned by copying paintings, they still create original work. An AI simply copies.

Yeah, algorithmically copying one's style with out permission isn't the same thing as a human mirroring art. It's not a skill.

You can create art with AI for sure but it's nothing but a tool (at least for now). And it's unethical to use art without permission in this context where it literally algorithmically copies the material.

When somebody uses a ML model to generate content, the skill is not their goal. The end result is.

If an AI simply copies, it should be easy as pie to tell me what artist they copied here.

If someone told me a human drew this, I would believe them. Looks original as anything else people have made.

It doesn't copy from a single artist. It's an amalgamation of a bunch of different artists' work. That's literally the entire concept of a model.

That is what people do. I like to write stories and my ideas are a mashup of books that I read.

Describe the criteria you use to determine whether something is "creation".