A Far-Right Court Just Admitted a Truth That Abortion Foes Want to Hide

MicroWave@lemmy.world to politics @lemmy.world – 742 points –
A Far-Right Court Just Admitted a Truth That Abortion Foes Want to Hide
slate.com

When the Supreme Court overturned Roe v. Wade, it claimed to be removing the judiciary from the abortion debate. In reality, it simply gave the courts a macabre new task: deciding how far states can push a patient toward death before allowing her to undergo an emergency abortion.

On Tuesday, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 5th Circuit offered its own answer, declaring that Texas may prohibit hospitals from providing “stabilizing treatment” to pregnant patients by performing an abortion—withholding the procedure until their condition deteriorates to the point of grievous injury or near-certain death.

The ruling proves what we already know: Roe’s demise has transformed the judiciary into a kind of death panel that holds the power to elevate the potential life of a fetus over the actual life of a patient.

160

You are viewing a single comment

We had two years where Dems controlled the House, Senate, and presidency…

No. We had two years where Dems controlled the House and the Presidency and were challenged at every move by Sinema and Manchin. What specifically would have convinced Sinema and, especially, Manchin to agree to codify abortion? Because, if you weren't aware, the Democrats did try to codify abortion and Manchin specifically blocked it.

So what should they have done to convince Manchin? Or do you think they could have convinced a Republican to take their side? Because I sure as hell don't.

and were challenged at every move by Sinema and Manchin

I'd take that as an excuse if Biden hasn't spent the whole primary and election telling us that he can get dem legislation thru a Republican Senate....

Then we (luckily) end up with 50 D senators, and Biden told us it was pointless to try.

That doesn't really change anything, because Biden was already expecting to have to fight a Republican Senate and get a couple votes.

Hell, the whole reason we got 50 was the GA runoff when Biden was still saying 50 D's would be enough to pass the whole platform.

Do you think Joe "Senate whisperer" Biden just didn't know who Manchin was?

If so, why couldn't he still get those few R votes he promised he could get?

So it’s Biden’s fault that republicans are opposing anything the democrats are doing?

You’re playing right into their game with that kind of thinking.

It's my fault for listening to what Biden said he could?

I should have known he would blatantly lie to get elected and then immediately act like I'm an idiot for thinking what he said was true?

But also...

This time I should listen to Biden and it totally won't happen again....

Have you ever thought about why voter turnout goes down for incumbents?

Not always.

Trump got more votes in 2020 than he did in 2016 and there's no reason to believe Biden isn't going to get more considering it's an exact repeat.

Biden has been fixing Trump's dumpster fire and most reasonable people can see that.

Total votes almost always go up due to population increase over the last 4 years...

When people talk about turnout, we're talking about percent of eligible voters.

That says overall turnout increased 7%< not that trump increased his by 7%... Not sure if you noticed, but he lost 2020...

And that's not even getting into how trump did what Republican voters wanted, Biden hasn't .

So even if Trump's went up, what does that have to do with Biden's?

But I'm tired of not noticing your username till I'm roped into conversations.

I'd rather just never see it again, so that's what I'm doing. Don't expect anymore replies, I'll never see them.

Have a good day u/SatansMaggotyCumFart

Your comment:

Have you ever thought about why voter turnout goes down for incumbents?

My response:

...voter turnout rose 7 percentage points over 2016, resulting in a total of 66% of U.S. adult citizens casting a ballot in the 2020 election.

So you move goalposts and get pissed off for being called out and block me? En

Then we (luckily) end up with 50 D senators, and Biden told us it was pointless to try.

They literally tried. Did you even read my link?

Manchin isn't even a Democrat anymore, and even before he made that official, it was already de facto true.

  1. So you're saying even tho it was obvious, Biden and his people didn't see it coming?

  2. How does that change Bidens presumption that it would be a Republican Senate?