No more Pornhub? That will depend on what happens with a Senate bill

L4sBot@lemmy.worldmod to Technology@lemmy.world – 83 points –
cbc.ca

No more Pornhub? That will depend on what happens with a Senate bill::A Senate bill might cause the owners of Pornhub to block access to the site in Canada, its owners say.

44

You are viewing a single comment

How do you ban a VPN? If I connect to a server that's a big cloud provider, how do you know the connection is to a VPN or a website?

It's not feasible to prevent it completely, but you can certainly make it harder for the average person and discourage usage by simply outlawing it. That's what China is doing at least.

China is not successful in it, since you can still use a VPN in China. You can even self host

Somehow I knew when I wrote that comment that someone would interpret "it's possible to discourage VPN usage and make it harder for the layman" as "it's possible to prevent VPN usage completely and China is 100% successful at doing that". China hasn't gone all in on blocking VPN traffic either way, since corporations can still use them and tourists don't like having their internet connection dropped without warning (which they actually did at one point), but someday they might and it will probably be enough to prevent the majority from using VPNs to circumvent government censorship.

It's technically impossible without blocking cloudflare and breaking most of the internet. You can route your VPN through cloudflare, so there's that

With deep packet inspection they can detect a VPN protocol connection attempt and drop it. There are already countries utilizing this method.

Only works if you use a protocol that can be detected.

https://github.com/XTLS/Xray-core/ has been defeating Chinese censors

Yes, my point is that banning protocols will kill all the commercial VPN offerings. Restricting a big size of the population. Obscure protocols like X-Ray can work but not everyone can set it up.

And I think you can also raise some suspicion if you use too much bandwidth on that connection. GBs of data consumption from MyTotallyLegitWebsite.me can raise eyebrows. And that would be the only thing needed for a court notice or a visit by the police, depending upon the country. And in anti-democratic countries you're guilty until proven innocent anyway.

There are commercial xray servers where you just share them with people for a subscription price and it automatically updates with the freshest info

GBs of data from a connection is not that uncommon. There's a thing called cloudflare and you might already be hitting those IPs for gigabytes per month. You can route the VPN through cloudflare so it just looks like you're visiting a lot of websites hosted by cloudflare

13 more...