Playboy image from 1972 gets ban from IEEE computer journals

mox@lemmy.sdf.org to Technology@lemmy.world – 299 points –
Playboy image from 1972 gets ban from IEEE computer journals
arstechnica.com
187

You are viewing a single comment

Censorship is a slippery slope.

So I take it you think the Washington Commanders should have stayed the Washington Redskins because not censoring is more important than it being disrespectful to a large group of people? My eyes would fall out if they rolled any harder.

No one's censoring the history or saying it never happened, we're just saying "Maybe there's a better, less controversial image to use for this purpose." Which really shouldn't be a very controversial take at all.

It's not like you can't see the old Redskins logo on Wikipedia, or that the Wikipedia entry for the Lenna image would disappear. That would be censorship, not this. This is just "don't use this controversial image in professional documents like science research." Literally, specifically, IEEE journals.

Uh, a consensual photograph of a naked woman, especially a cropped headshot of her, is not the same as a racial slur.

Since you obviously feel strongly about this issue, you might consider your bias as a reason to read more carefully. Please don't put words in my mouth.

Censorship is a slippery slope.

I read it very carefully. I'm sorry you aren't capable of backing up what you said in the face of someone pointing out that isn't actually censorship.

Further, as many have pointed out, there are plenty of similar reference images available. Not using this image will not impede scientific progress, as you have so implied. (Honestly after 50 years, it's arguable that we have much better reference images now.)

I’m sorry you aren’t capable of backing up what you said in the face of someone pointing out that isn’t actually censorship.

censor

cen·​sor ˈsen(t)-sər

2 of 2
verb

censored; censoring ˈsen(t)-sə-riŋ

transitive verb

: to examine in order to suppress (see suppress sense 2) or delete anything considered objectionable

also : to suppress or delete as objectionable

[Edit: formatting]

1 more...
1 more...
1 more...

It’s not like you can’t see the old Redskins logo on Wikipedia, or that the Wikipedia entry for the Lenna image would disappear.

Give it time.

1 more...