AI Suggestions

JPDev@programming.dev to Programmer Humor@programming.dev – 761 points –
62

You are viewing a single comment

Glorified autocomplete. That, and Clippy.

Glorified autocomplete

That's what I need most of the time, though. I don't see these AI things as replacing programmers or writing large chunks of code. I just see them as an improvement over the autocompletion/IntelliSense features we're all using already.

Autocomplete and Clippy havent translated a script from one language into another for me without major errors yet.

Clippy was occasionally useful as it could offer shortcuts you didn't necessarily know about.

This is just bad autocomplete

I was lucky enough to get in on my company's beta test for copilot.

When I hear people say it's bad, all that tells me is that they are either completely ignorant and have never really used it, or they aren't good at learning how to use new tools.

The example shown is setting a timer, then copilot suggests timeright value.

Contextually, it is bad autocomplete.

In practice, chatgpt4 is incapable of producing code to my coding standards. Edit: to clarify, its incapable of doing that in a timely enough manner that it saves me any time.

The example shown was specifically selected because it's funny, not because it's representative.

The fact that you called the tool "chatgpt4" suggests you're not experienced with copilot. They're not the same thing even if they're using similar LLMs as a component.

I know its not chatgpt4, I never said it was?

That paragraph is on its own because it is a different topic. In this case I was using my own experience experimenting with chatgpt4 as to why I won't be using it any time soon.