Remember, remember

ShareMySims@sh.itjust.works to Lefty Memes@lemmy.dbzer0.com – 429 points –

ID: V from V for Vendetta saying "people should not be afraid of their governments, governments should be afraid of their people"

26

You are viewing a single comment
View all commentsShow the parent comment

The graphic novel has some differences, mostly related to the era it was written in. Do yourself a huge favor and go ahead and read it. Like Watchmen and The Killing Joke, it's not just the writing, but also the panel layout, colors, and framing.

Until you've read "This Vicious Cabaret" in it's original layout you haven't really experienced V for Vendetta.

They say that there's a broken light for every heart on Broadway

They say that life's a game, then they take the board away

They give you masks and costumes and an outline of the story

Then leave you all to improvise their vicious cabaret...

I do love watching film media first, and then reading the book. When the film version is done well, the book is like DVD extras. When the film is done poorly, the book redeems the story

Enjoy your DVD extras

Not many people I know personally like watching before reading but I definitely prefer it in that order as well. If I read an amazing book before watching its film adaptation, the film will never live up to the book. The Martian was this way for me.

So i have trouble visualizing things, particularly people, and especially faces. When i watch a show or movie i can register a face to a name, and that in turn let's me "see" them in my minds eye as I read.

The Expanse was just about perfect for that, i just had to mentally stretch Naomi to 2+meters tall, and things like that

I think I like reading first and then anything else. If the film is different or worse, it doesn't actually detract from the book. I try to look at it as someone having a try at a tribute rather than replacing the book. Hitchhikers Guide was different, and many complained, but "hey it's different" is a silly complaint when Hitchhikers Guide was different in literally every medium but film and book are always going to be the most seen. Foundation is different but nonetheless enjoyable. The emperor Cleon is never like that in the books but instead in the show, personifies the entire empire, ruthless, vain, powerful but performative, human and not. How else to portray a 10,000 year empire in a few dozen episodes of TV? I saw the Lord of the Rings films before the book but Christ I could not read those books without some higher level, more tangible image of what I am reading.

It's definitely my intention to read it at some point.

If we were neighbors I'd let you borrow my (very well-worn) copy

I appreciate that, thanks! Though it's less about getting a copy, and more about finding the time and brain space to actually read anything of any significant length. One day though..

Era is true, but not quite right.

Moore roughly described it as taking a graphic novel about British anarchism vs British fascism and turning it into a story about American neoliberalism vs neoconservativism and still setting it in Britain even though there wasn't anything British about it anymore.

Too right. It was a gross oversimplification, thank you for building on it