It's time to admit Lemmy has won the "the biggest reddit alternative" award, why it's time for all of us to consider supporting it (here's why) + reopening r/LemmyMigration

Lee Duna@lemmy.nz to Reddit@lemmy.world – 1734 points –
It's time to admit Lemmy has won the "the biggest reddit alternative" award, why it's time for all of us to consider supporting it (here's why) + reopening r/LemmyMigration
old.reddit.com
479

You are viewing a single comment

What was your negative experience?

Getting banned from ML for saying that Russia is commiting war crimes in Ukraine. And then again for saying that the US revolution didn't generally involve mass rape. And then again for calling an obvious troll out.

This last time, the ban reason was literally "Socsa." Which I guess is flattering, but being put on a short leash for not breaking any rules, while tankies are free to troll threads with pig shit gifs is not a positive experience.

The stuff you’re talking about is why a lot of people are turned off period. Which people have already made that point in this thread.

You’ll get banned on ML for much of anything. I’m banned in the memes community of all places. This is not dependent on the instance you decided to use.

I would say my hardest thing onboarding was actually understanding what each instance was really about. Your pretty much presented with endless choices seemingly and you can't really weigh every option.

Yeah that’s what you said in the comment I replied to. Was wondering what that negative experience you had was. Other then them defederating, shutting down, or having overall crappy uptime there’s not a whole lot of differences when using Lemmy.

For newcomers it's not clear what the significance of choosing an instance is, so that makes it hard to choose, and those potential downsides of choosing the wrong instance are actually pretty significant, or at least pretty annoying.

Yes I understand this. I’m just trying to open up the conversation on what those negatives are for people to see.

I see. There aren't other major negatives that come to mind, but those ones are very important.

Oh I see what you were getting at. The second half of my message talking about getting a negative impression was more so speculation on how someone might react to joining one of the more politically charged instances like lemmygrad or hexbear. Which could give a new user the impression that the fediverse was all like that.

I think they made it easier by having a suggested instances category at the top. And even back then, you could see the description of every instance listed. I think the main issue is having to submit the application, even though I know it doesn't have to be long and that it's necessary in this situation.