Which adaptation do you think has surpassed its source material in quality?

CaptainBasculin@lemmy.ml to Asklemmy@lemmy.ml – 98 points –
148

You are viewing a single comment

Starship Troopers - the book was extremely meh - the movie is excellent (and very relevant to modern day).

Clue - an excellent movie based off a fucking boardgame... ditto for Barbie now as well!

Mage the Acension is a TTRPG love letter to Ars Magicka and it blows it out of the water.

Paul Verhoeven really upped the ante on that one.

How would Hannah Arendt be relevant here? I read a short blurb about her philosophy especially in regards to authority but I haven't seen starship troopers

A hexbear or lemmygrad user could better explain this one, but its a deep-cut satirical comment on how nations that market themselves as "free" (but aren't), promote philosophies that group and demonize all their enemies into a single camp, and prop up writers like Arendt, who was one of the main ideological peddlers of western moral supremacy during the cold war.

Losurdo has a lot of good articles on this and Arendt specificaly, and also Gabriel Rockhill has some good articles about this too.

https://ia801609.us.archive.org/0/items/pdfy-dfBD-isycOcvHvqS/Domenico%20Losurdo%20--%20Towards%20a%20Critique%20of%20the%20Category%20of%20Totalitarianism.pdf

Ahhh, thank you. I'll give that link a read

I recently started reading Eichmann In Jerusalem, because I was aware it introduced the phrase "banality of evil" and always think of that in moral/ethical discussions about the real world (versus hypotheticals), and was immediately struck by how uncritical she was of zionism when it crops up in her reporting/writing. It's almost like just a quirk of some of the heads of state that is used to explain their politics, rather than anything with more sinister implications.

Perhaps this comes from some immature SJW-ish ideal that an author should always negatively represent harmful ideas—or maybe she does later and I'm just impatient—but it still strikes me as ironic that in the seminal work on The Banality of Evil, genocidal colonialism is treated as, well, banal.

Helldivers 2 is heavily inspired by the movie... And I would say it's better than it.

PS: Mage - The Ascension ♥️

While I like the theme etc. of Helldivers 2, I do wish they went a bit further than that. This kind of satire is best when it forces small bits of unease on the audience, like the ending of Starship Troopers - "it feels fear!", and everyone celebrates. There are bits and pieces surrounding the gameplay loop (e.g. something like "never talk to the enemy, destroy them for democracy", forgot the exact line), but it's rare enough to be easy to ignore.

1 more...
1 more...