Chuck Schumer’s ambitious plan to take the Supreme Court down a peg

jeffw@lemmy.worldmod to News@lemmy.world – 337 points –
Chuck Schumer’s ambitious plan to take the Supreme Court down a peg
vox.com
29

You are viewing a single comment

Senate shenanigans are always fun to read about.

Also, we learned that they're "separate but equal" branches of government in school. Let's see if the legislative branch can claw back some level of influence.

Uhhh couple of y’all are using the phrase “separate but equal” way out of context.

That was the key phrase for Plessy v. Ferguson aka the basis for the formal establishment of segregation in the US.

“Separation of powers” and “checks and balances” are the guiding principles for our 3 branches.

Oy, of course you're right 😅

"Coequal" I think was the term I remember learning.

…we learned that they're "separate but equal" branches of government in school.

Samsies. But then again, I don’t think normal people (our founders included) ever expected a willful collusion by a party to stack those branches of government in their favor.

The founders didn't intend for the SCOTUS to be an equal branch of government. They just kinda started doing constitutional review, and multiple founders were explicit about how that's not what they intended.

More like our founders would be shocked that we haven't rewritten the Constitution yet, and horrified that centuries later we're treating it like some divine scripture

There are multiple mechanisms in there to modify or even rewrite the whole thing. They totally saw this coming, they were pretty vocal about it. They hoped future generations would build on their work, not enshrine it