I have a love-hate relationship with GTK: on one hand, it's aesthetically pleasing to me; on the other hand, CLIENT-SIDE DECORATIONS CAN KISS MY ASS.
I'm a baby dev trying to collect some brain wrinkles. Can you expand that last point? What's the downside of client side decorations? What's a better alternative?
I imagine it's hard to debug and hard to ensure it's consistent across machines due to different environments?
Maybe I'm misunderstanding but for clarification, the fact they're drawn by the client actually means they can always be the same across different environments. This is in opposition to server-side decorations which are drawn by the desktop environment and should match the environment as a result. That said, server-side decorations are largely much less extensible than client side ones.
Ah that makes more sense!
It's a bad thing that they're always the same, I don't like having window borders or buttons and use a keyboard based hyprland setup, this is just a bunch of wasted space for me
Honestly, I don't really understand the hate that client-side decorations get. I find that they're generally pretty useful and good.
I think a lot of it comes from people who want to 'rice' and theme their desktops but I personally think that dream has sailed. The kind of theming people want on Linux systems is simply not possible without massive amounts of work and downgrades to accessibility, security and usability.
I'm very happy with my rice and the dream has not sailed at all, I have had no downgrades, to accessibility, or usability with a custom theme, in fact, I'd go so far as to say custom themes enable better accessibility and usability for me
security? It's just a css file?
@EveryMuffinIsNowEncrypted I don't think CSD would be a big nuisance on a mobile phone or tablet, pretty much all apps nowadays have it.
I have a love-hate relationship with GTK: on one hand, it's aesthetically pleasing to me; on the other hand, CLIENT-SIDE DECORATIONS CAN KISS MY ASS.
I'm a baby dev trying to collect some brain wrinkles. Can you expand that last point? What's the downside of client side decorations? What's a better alternative?
I imagine it's hard to debug and hard to ensure it's consistent across machines due to different environments?
Maybe I'm misunderstanding but for clarification, the fact they're drawn by the client actually means they can always be the same across different environments. This is in opposition to server-side decorations which are drawn by the desktop environment and should match the environment as a result. That said, server-side decorations are largely much less extensible than client side ones.
Ah that makes more sense!
It's a bad thing that they're always the same, I don't like having window borders or buttons and use a keyboard based hyprland setup, this is just a bunch of wasted space for me
Honestly, I don't really understand the hate that client-side decorations get. I find that they're generally pretty useful and good.
I think a lot of it comes from people who want to 'rice' and theme their desktops but I personally think that dream has sailed. The kind of theming people want on Linux systems is simply not possible without massive amounts of work and downgrades to accessibility, security and usability.
I'm very happy with my rice and the dream has not sailed at all, I have had no downgrades, to accessibility, or usability with a custom theme, in fact, I'd go so far as to say custom themes enable better accessibility and usability for me
security? It's just a css file?
@EveryMuffinIsNowEncrypted I don't think CSD would be a big nuisance on a mobile phone or tablet, pretty much all apps nowadays have it.
@imblue