Texas independence vote is imminent, group's leader says

HLMenckenFan@lemmy.worldmod to politics @lemmy.world – 174 points –
Texas independence vote is imminent, group's leader says
newsweek.com
117

You are viewing a single comment

Counterpoint: The UK isn't allowed to leave the EU. There's no mechanism.

That's not a counterpoint. The EU is not a country. The EU is an economic and financial understanding between many different countries in order to collaborate on things like currency, trade, tariffs etc. Even if the EU was a country which, I can't stress this enough, it isn't, the EU agreement has clear rules for leaving it. Unlike the US Constitution, which isn't like the EU agreement in very many ways at all.

Having no mechanism and being specifically legislated against are two different things. Brexit is the former, this sounds like the latter.

There's a difference between having no official mechanism, and having the largest military in the world knock on your door to tell you that you can't do something.

If Texas really truly tried to leave the United States, it would be war, and they would not win.

To clarify:

Even if an unambiguous majority of Texas would say "we'd like to turn Texas into an independent country", you'd rather force them to stay by force of arms?

You don't get to steal hundreds of thousands of miles of land from a country and wander off. War would happen. Would I like it? No, war is terrible.

Plus, they wouldn't survive. Let's say we didn't retake our land. The inevitable embargo would destroy them. War is war. Financial war is also kinda war.

2 more...

Yes absolutely. Just like in the Civil War, which I am also glad we won.

2 more...
2 more...

A 5-year war wasn't fought in Europe over whether or not the UK was allowed to leave the EU.

And you can smoke pot and get abortions in texas because they’re legal in Illinois. No the US actually has been tested on whether or not states have the right to secede and the answer is no, we had a civil war over it

2 more...