My understanding is that the judge is chosen by lottery, out of a certain number of judges in the same district. Since that particular district in FL only has a few judges there was always a pretty solid chance that she could be chosen. It wasn’t a certainty, but definitely a good chance.
That’s why her actions are such a betrayal of the justice system. It shouldn’t matter which judge was randomly selected. To anyone with eyeballs, she has shown a distressing preference for the person who appointed her, and has shown over and over again that she doesn’t have the relevant experience to oversee a case of this magnitude. If she were a qualified and impartial judge, she would appreciate the fact that she appears to be completely biased, and recuse herself.
Even if tons of legal experts are wrong about her, which at this point seems pretty unlikely, her duty is to step aside and allow a judge who still has the public’s trust to oversee the case.
Seems pretty obvious to me that presiding over a case that involves the person that gave a judge their job shouldn't be allowed in the first place...
Hmmm, what about the opposite - a judge chosen by the opposition?
Like, what if it was Biden on trial for some reason and it was a judge chosen by Trump. Would you have the same concern?
I agree it sucks and she clearly sucks, but I'm not sure a simple rule like your saying would definitely make sense.
Unless there's been a bunch of recent deaths it shouldn't be too hard to find a judge named by neither Trump nor Biden.
Why does the executive branch have any say over the judicial branch? Shouldn't they operate independently of each other?
Why does the executive branch have any say over the judicial branch?
That would be the Constitution.
I believe Article II, Section 2.
Coming in with citations, nice.
Too bad it doesn’t make sense to do it that way anymore.
I asked why not where
And I told you why...and where in case you were interested.
We have reached the point where politics has so deeply invaded all levels of government that the system is broken beyond repair. Now, it's just a battle for the soul of the monster.
My understanding is that the judge is chosen by lottery, out of a certain number of judges in the same district. Since that particular district in FL only has a few judges there was always a pretty solid chance that she could be chosen. It wasn’t a certainty, but definitely a good chance.
That’s why her actions are such a betrayal of the justice system. It shouldn’t matter which judge was randomly selected. To anyone with eyeballs, she has shown a distressing preference for the person who appointed her, and has shown over and over again that she doesn’t have the relevant experience to oversee a case of this magnitude. If she were a qualified and impartial judge, she would appreciate the fact that she appears to be completely biased, and recuse herself.
Even if tons of legal experts are wrong about her, which at this point seems pretty unlikely, her duty is to step aside and allow a judge who still has the public’s trust to oversee the case.
Seems pretty obvious to me that presiding over a case that involves the person that gave a judge their job shouldn't be allowed in the first place...
Hmmm, what about the opposite - a judge chosen by the opposition?
Like, what if it was Biden on trial for some reason and it was a judge chosen by Trump. Would you have the same concern?
I agree it sucks and she clearly sucks, but I'm not sure a simple rule like your saying would definitely make sense.
Unless there's been a bunch of recent deaths it shouldn't be too hard to find a judge named by neither Trump nor Biden.
Why does the executive branch have any say over the judicial branch? Shouldn't they operate independently of each other?
That would be the Constitution.
I believe Article II, Section 2.
Coming in with citations, nice.
Too bad it doesn’t make sense to do it that way anymore.
I asked why not where
And I told you why...and where in case you were interested.
We have reached the point where politics has so deeply invaded all levels of government that the system is broken beyond repair. Now, it's just a battle for the soul of the monster.