Australians look set to vote against Indigenous voice in parliament

Lee Duna@lemmy.nz to World News@lemmy.world – 300 points –
Australians look set to vote against Indigenous voice in parliament
theguardian.com
106

You are viewing a single comment

I’m voting ‘no’.

If you want a job in politics with a $200K salary, earn it. I don’t care what colour your skin is.

Why is the assumption that the individuals who will receive these jobs won’t be qualified for them?

He's just repackaging the usual "hiring quotas" idiocy where they pretend that there's people in board rooms saying "well this man has every degree that Harvard offers but unfortunately we need to hire a woman so we're giving the job to this high school drop out that was visibly drunk in the interview".

The reality is that any job opening ends up with a pool of candidates, all of which are qualified for the job and it won't be any different here.

But they can't say the truth, so they say shit like this instead.

I don’t care what colour your skin is.

A very popular saying among racists.

Methinks somehow they do care what colour their skin is...

Surely this is more like adding a couple extra constituencies that are a bit geographically splintered? I know the powers and structure aren't identical to MPs, but it's not like you're voting to just give three specific guys jobs for life

It’s likely 100s of jobs for life, with government pension added at retirement. Math that out over 25 years and it’s somewhere around $500 million dollars.

If my tax dollars are contributing to $500M in my lifetime, I want it going to people with degrees and a fuckton of experience.

The last time we let someone into politics with no experience and no degree, we got Pauline Hanson. I’m not voting yes to 100 more Pauline Hansons.

About a quarter of the MPs in parliament haven't got degrees. Plenty of their staff won't have either.

$500,000,000 over 25 years is less than a dollar per person per year. Let's not pretend that the number you've come up with there is some bank-breaking extravagance for a large economy over the course of decades.

So why do you believe non-white people couldn't possibly have "degrees and a fuckton of experience?"

Because the people put into these Voice positions will be Elders of Indigenous communities.

And since I personally worked on the 2013-16, $10M Indigenous communities research project for utilities connection and communication strategy, I know that 11% of the people in those communities are literate and the data point for tertiary-level education was so low it was rounded to 0.

To communicate the process of utilities connection, it was determined to best use pictures, which is still the strategy today.

Any more questions, hero?

Ah, so it's not that you're racist because you believe indigenous people are inherently less capable, but instead that you're racist because you see nothing wrong with perpetuating institutional racism. "Disadvantage must be maintained!" is your credo.

You got me.

Now don’t forget to downvote me (you can keep your upvote).

@Art3sian

you can keep your upvote

Just FYI those of us on kbin can see if you actually upvoted someone or not.

”Those of us on KBIN are…” Haha, shut the fuck up.

You get an auto upvote when you post. I didn’t downvote him. Think before you speak, you Magic the Gathering-playing dickhead.

lol. Not sure where the M:TG comment is coming from, but I assume you scoured this guy's profile or something. The shit you're into is just as nerdy (given a cursory look at your own profile) so you can fuck right off with that criticism. Please, go find a racist echo chamber where you can be praised for your ignorant vitriol, you sad, sad troll

Ooh, look at you all brave and shit. You looking in the mirror while you write this?

1 more...
1 more...
1 more...