‘Extraordinary’: Biden administration staffers’ growing dissent against Gaza policy

Collision Resistance@lemmy.world to politics @lemmy.world – 229 points –
‘Extraordinary’: Biden administration staffers’ growing dissent against Gaza policy
theguardian.com
89

You are viewing a single comment

I'm probably just speaking for myself, but this particular dynamic actually makes me feel better about supporting Biden. I think Joe Biden himself is a contemptible dumbass whose policy imagination is stuck in a past that never even actually existed, but I think he's had to surround himself with a lot of staffers in their 20s 30s and 40s who aren't so terminally dense on things like Israel and student loans and reproductive healthcare and labor unions, and they can actually make him evolve and be a little bit less of a boomer than he otherwise would be. Hopefully they're able to keep the pressure up.

Exactly, Trunp would be purging these people from his administration, and wouldn't be holding Israel back at all, if anything Trump might send troops in or order some strikes himself just to feel like he's partipating in the slaughter.

Biden has shown that he's movable on issues whereas Trump would just take a sharpie to those issues, or worse, far worse.

"movable on issues"

he took office and immediately backtracked on campaign promises firing staffers, not defending healthcare, told rail workers they did not have a right to ask for better, and not to mention the rest and the recent

campaign promises that went against his and his vice's whole career so big surprise there

The International Brotherhood of Electrical Workers says:

“We’re thankful that the Biden administration played the long game on sick days and stuck with us for months after Congress imposed our updated national agreement,” Russo said. “Without making a big show of it, Joe Biden and members of his administration in the Transportation and Labor departments have been working continuously to get guaranteed paid sick days for all railroad workers."

And I hate to tell you this, but if you want a president who doesn't back down on any campaign promises, you will never, EVER be satisfied. Because realistic promises don't inspire voters & win elections, optimism does (at least for Dems, GOP prefers fear)

Follow up on the rail workers thing. I had to eat a bit of crow on that one myself.

How is he movable? All he’s done is send more weapons and spread disinformation/propaganda even israel said were lies…

Joe Biden being the one doing it just causes liberals to protest less than If trump was doing it. Same thing with Covid, Biden laughed at masks and took his off while sick and has done nothing to stop the pandemic that is infecting over 2 million people in the US a day and killing 1,000 a day. That’s multiple 9/11s a week and yet liberals act like it’s nothing cuz it’s not trump in charge anymore.

... has done nothing to stop the pandemic...

Bullshit.

A year in, experts assess Biden's hits and misses on handling the pandemic:

Goal 1: Restore trust with the American people- Experts say on this front, the Biden administration has not made much progress, although they acknowledge how challenging a problem it is.

Goal 2: Mount a safe, effective, comprehensive vaccination campaign- His administration made huge strides in expanding vaccine supply and access, experts say.

Goal 3: Mitigate spread through expanding masking, testing, treatment, data, workforce and clear public health standards- This is an area where the administration has fallen short

Goal 4: Immediately expand emergency relief and exercise the Defense Production Act- The president scored an early win signing the American Rescue Plan into law- "this administration in particular has been quite skillful with respect to its use of the DPA."- Still, "the main message here is too little, too late on masks and testing," From Turner's perspective, the current supply problems have less to do with underutilized federal authority and more to do with the virus itself

Goal 5: Safely reopen schools, businesses and travel, while protecting workers- Schools continue to be a contentious issue the Supreme Court blocking the White House's attempt to require vaccination or tests for employers with 100 or more workers.

Goal 6: Protect those most at risk and advance equity, including across racial, ethnic and rural/urban lines- The administration has been "moderately successful" on this front, says Benjamin of the APHA.

Goal 7: Restore U.S. leadership globally and build better preparedness for future threats.- This "is certainly an area where the administration promised big but has fallen short so far," she adds.

You can criticize the Biden COVID response, which seems to be a mixed bag. But you absolutely cannot say he's done nothing. And he's certainly moved us in the right direction, unlike Trump who was the single largest driver of coronavirus misinformation.

He laughed at masks during his recent infection and took it off while around people. Hasnt launched a campaign for clean air, is doing nothing to increase booster rates, hasnt mentioned long covid once, isnt funding long covid treatments or clean air initiatives for schools or businesses.

He hasnt mentioned long covid. He should be doing press about long covid and how people should be avoiding reinfection still by masking and cleaning the air with air purifiers and upgraded hvacs but hes not because he wants everyone to pretend covid is over and be in the office.

That initiative is a couple million dollars for a disease thats killing and disabling millions of people that he isnt talking about at all while sending billions for weapons for genocide. Why isnt he talking about clean air, and acting like its no big deal. This should be a war time style effort to combatting the pandemic but he hasnt whispered it.

His administration has been so bad at public health messaging people are wondering “whats in the air” and shocked that “covid is still a thing”. The cdc is still putting out messaging about washing hands and they still havent put out a plan or regulations for co2 monitoring and clean air initiatives in federal buildings, hospitals, classrooms, and businesses.

He hasnt mentioned long covid.

He hasnt whispered it.

...

That initiative is a couple million dollars

He has literally enacted policy to address this. You can critique that it's not enough, but you cannot say he hasn't done anything.

If verbally saying something is what does it for you: "“We are bringing agencies together to make sure Americans with long Covid, who have a disability, have access to the rights and resources that are due under disability law,” Biden said during his remarks."

I imagine his speech wasn't whispered.

Movable? Why the do you think his staffers are quitting? Genocide Joe has no plans to change course precisely because people like you support Genocide.

After bombing 20k people he bypasses Congress to send more bombs to israel. He is not movable. He is a pure Zionazi.

Israel tried to get Trump to start a war with Iran when he was in power, and Trump didn't. There is little chance that Trump would do much worse than Biden.

There is little chance that Trump would do much worse than Biden

Bullshit. Trump praises & enables authoritarians worldwide, refused to support the two state solution, emboldened Israeli supremacists by recognizing Jerusalem as their capitol & moved the US embassy there, and cut aid to Palestinian refugees by 80%..

it's not like biden restored that aid, moved the embassy back, and has been advocating a two state solution. he emboldened the israeli supremacists by saying he is a zionist

it's not like Biden restored that aid

Yes he fucking has.

... has been advocating two state solution

Yes he fucking has

your links indicate that the aid has not been restored and he hasn't said shit about a Palestinian state since 2022, but he did just say he is a zionist.

aid has not been restored

Yes it fucking has "President Joe Biden has restored hundreds of millions of dollars of UN funding that was cut under President Donald Trump."

Hasn't said shit about Palestinian state since 2022

Yes he fucking has. "Biden Says a ‘Real’ Palestinian State Must Come After War" - 11/16/23

JFC this shit is so easy to Google.

your link does not say it has been fully restored, because it hasn't. and coming in during a genocide to say"when you're done we should talk" is not championing the Palestinian people.

There is little chance that Trump would do much worse than Biden.

This was your original statement. I have demonstrated beyond a doubt that it is absolutely false.

OK so? Biden is actively killing thousands of Palestinian children. Trump cut the Iran deal but he didn't star a war like israel wanted. Trump withdrew from Afghanistan too.

When you follow the money it looks like Genocide Joe is by far the favorite choice for israeli lobbies.

Pro-israel donor recipients.

1 Biden, Joe (D) President $3,753,244

2 Perdue, David (R-GA) Senate $1,053,098

3 Trump, Donald (R) President $894,032

Israel really loves Genocide Joe and we can see why. He will even bypass Congress to continue their genocide.

actively killing

No. Biden is aiding and abetting Israel which is terrible, but there are zero US troops in Gaza, and Biden is not directing Israel's Gaza invasion.

Trump withdrew from Afghanistan too.

Umm ok, if you're considering all the conflicts of the world, then the genocide of the Climate Crisis is the most devastating. You gonna fuckin tell me how much better Trump is than Biden on climate?

I don't think he's a dumbass, I think he's a man in his 80s that hasn't/can't adapt to the times and needs more convincing than should be necessary. I honestly think his heart is in the right place, but he's just too damn old.

I honestly think his heart is in the right place, but he’s just too damn old.

There's no "right place" for a heart that supports genocide to be.

Heck yeah supporting genocide let's go boys.