In your opinion, which distro should I try to edit videos stably?

dez@lemmy.ml to Linux@lemmy.ml – 57 points –

I'm feeling more tired about Windows, and the reason I haven't switched yet to Linux is because I need some programs that only exist on Windows. But, at this point, I'm focusing on ditching these programs and finding alternatives for them..

Last year, I experienced Linux Mint, but, at least on my PC, it feels clunky when I need to do some little video editions and I found it more stable on Windows.

However, I'm going to try again Linux distros with a virtual box, but I'm a little """scared""" to move on again to Linux Mint since my last experience with editing videos.

I don't need an extremely powerful program to make these editions. Olive, or something like that, suits me perfectly. So, in your opinion, which distro should I try on one virtual box for my daily use for these purposes?

Making a dual boot, from your point of view, is problematic? I see so many different opinions about dual boot, but at this time, I don't know what to think.


My pc

  • Processor: AMD Ryzen 3 PRO 2100GE with Radeon veja graphics

  • RAM: 8gb


Edit : ty for the replys so far, mates

54

You are viewing a single comment

I wouldn’t recommend editing videos using a virtual machine, the performance will probably be quite miserable.

How noob am I, huh? Ty for the advice mate

Edit: zero irony here

The issue is that programs can't directly use your gpu when using a virtual machine

I guess you never heard of GPU Passthrough... https://github.com/bryansteiner/gpu-passthrough-tutorial/

GPU passthrough requires two GPUs, a system with compatible components, a lot of caffeine and a lot of patience. Not something for someone who wants something that just works.

It only requires it if you want the host to have a gpu, too. Otherwise, single-gpu passthrough is very much possible

The chasm between "possible" and "click this option to enable" is vast.

That's the case with proper hardware passthrough either way. Just wanted to make it clear that running a VM doesn't automatically bring the need for two GPUs

My experience with single GPU passthrough on Proxmox to a media VM was pretty positive, especially for it being an old Nvidia card. Even as someone doing it for the first time, it just took about 10 minutes to figure out the passthrough itself and another ~15 to figure out some driver issues. And it's worked perfectly since then. All in all much better than what I'd expected.

And your hardware supports it. It's still a recent-enough thing that not all hardware does. My old laptop with a 1070 nVidia does not, for example. Sure it's not a new machine, but it's also not that old and is the sort of thing a self-hoster would typically be using as a makeshift server. My other systems are even older...

The GPU I used is actually a 1080, with a (rapidly declining in usefulness) Intel 4690k. But I suppose laptop vs desktop can certainly make all the difference. What I really want is GPU virtualization, which I've heard AMD supports, but I'm not about to buy a new GPU when what I've got works fine.

My understanding is that it's a combination of GPU and motherboard. It'll be great once this has been done long enough that 10yr old hardware supports it though.

GPU virtualization I haven't heard of - thanks! I'll look into that.

What I said especially applies for single GPU passthrough, minus the two GPU part, I say that because I've done that on Desktop.

Single GPU passthrough (for me) was a journey of misery where a series of bash scripts with crude busyloop synchronization kept me from having no display output and needing to restart my system to test my changes again.

It's probably the last thing I'd recommend for someone who wants something that works, unless you know something I don't.

And integrated GPU counts, so you could use the integrated one for the host and a discrete card for the guest.

That's a really nice option, yeah. No need for the extra expense when the CPU you use or are going to buy has an iGPU anyway

Either he never heard of it or he decided he did not want to bother following the 200 page tutorial filled with fiddly bits.

I know this exists but from what I understand, OP is using VirtualBox, which doesn't support it and instead of going through the effort to set it up, you might as well just dual boot

OP probably doesn't have two GPUs in their computer.

I'm probably wrong, but isn't supposed to work if my CPU have a iGPU and I have a GPU? I genuinely ask, I'm not sure.

His CPU has integrated graphics. He can do full passthrough.

Now, if he's doing that with a Type 2 hypervisor, I suspect the performance will still be lackluster for video editing, if it's even supported.

Which means he's also going to have to learn to use KVM.

Did OP mention a dedicated GPU? I'd assume a rather low end 2100GE wouldn't likely be paired with a dGPU.

Very useful tip for a linux newbie with a laptop which has only igpu.

He's also very clearly going to be running the vm with a Windows host... More likely than not that means virtualbox, not spending money on software / hardware that does it well and easily on windows just to test out... Truly the best option here for OP is dual boot.

Try to double your ram and if you don't have ssd, get one. Your cpu and gpu is powerful enough for light video editing. Also amd drivers are shipped in the Linux Kernel so you don't need to do anything for them.