Who would win?

Herbal Gamer@sh.itjust.works to Lemmy Shitpost@lemmy.world – 1040 points –
130

You are viewing a single comment

Some context regarding this meme. The police officer is a war veteran, who probably has massive PTSD and reacted accordingly.

Now why the hell would the police service hire a guy who is clearly unfit for service is a major American moment.

Do you have any evidence of the "war veteran" part of this, or literally anything to indicate that he has PTSD besides your own assertion that he "probably" has it? The only thing I can find is that he was in Afghanistan but never saw any combat. Are there things in Afghanistan that could cause PTSD? Sure. Is there any evidence that he has PTSD? Not that I've seen.

You know who probably does have massive PTSD? The cuffed guy in the back that was almost executed by two cops because one of them was so effing stupid that he thought he'd been shot by an acorn. He did not "react accordingly." He reacted like a trigger-happy moron. The only useful part of this is that he's resigned.

The talibans Asymetrical warfare and the resulting Paranoya itself can give PTSD

If you spend years always expecting an ambush, always being told to expect an ambush, you will see an ambush everywhere. Even if you never were actually ambushed.

Not that i'm defending him, but asymetrical warfare can and will fuck you up.

The Taliban's methods of warfare, in and of themselves, don't even meet criterion A for a PTSD diagnosis. The man wouldn't necessarily have to be in combat to meet that, but it's a lot more likely if he did (which, by all evidence I've seen, he didn't).

Being paranoid is not PTSD.

Which diagnostic standard are you using? None of the ones I have use letters.

I tend to diagnose with better tests than a physician's desk reference, but you do you.

Apparently whatever you're using doesn't have letters in it, so I assume it also doesn't have words, since those tend to be made of letters. I'm fine with this. You can do whatever the voices and crystals are telling you.

The American’s asymmetrical warfare and the resulting paranoia itself can give you PTSD.

If you spend years always expecting a drone bombing your wedding, always being told to expect a drone bombing your wedding, you will see a drone bombing your wedding everywhere.

Even if your wedding never were actually drone bombed.

Not that i'm defending him but asymmetrical warfare can and will fuck you up.

And my question is, why should I give respect to someone who is violating rights of individuals domesticly as a police officer, and has likley committed war crimes and rights violations abrod, or atleast aided and abeded said war crimes. I only see this as more meme worthy. I understand PTSD is no joke, but at some point, the position of power and betrayal of your class removes the sympathy I would otherwise have for you

Sorry if my message didn't convey this.

I didn't ask for sympathy for anyone on this. It's more towards the process is absolutely fucking broken. It was obvious that something like that can happen to any person with more than 2 brain cells. And yet, the decisions we were made to put a person in a situation where he was bound to fail.

PTSD is not their fault, but it is their responsibility to deal with and they should not be employed in a position where that condition could engager the general public. Like it did. If I'm allergic to peanuts, I shouldn't be hired in a place that processes them. And even in that example, I'm only putting myself at risk.

Speculation, but having seen similarly hypervigilent and jumpy people get hired locally, they were hired for office duty, promote to field work and that's where they fucked up. But it's just three dudes I've seen that happen to, I wouldn't draw industry wide conclusions from that.