Donna Summer Estate Says Kanye West Used ‘I Feel Love’ Without Permission on ‘Vultures 1’ Track

bravepair@lemm.ee to News@lemmy.world – 256 points –
Donna Summer Estate Says Kanye West Used ‘I Feel Love’ Without Permission on ‘Vultures 1’ Track
billboard.com
13

I think we can all agree at this point that Kanye West is a shitty person.

Was that ever in doubt?

Some people used to just think he was just mentally ill, but it's clear he's both a bad person and mentally ill.

Mental illness is not an excuse for things like bigotry and violating copyright law.

and violating copyright law

Eh, copyright law sucks ass. He's still a complete ass, though.

I'm all for sampling, but this is pretty damning-

“Kanye West… asked permission to use Donna Summer’s song I Feel Love, he was denied… he changed the words, had someone re sing it or used AI but it’s I Feel Love… copyright infringement!!!” said a statement posted in an Instagram Story on the official Donna Summer account Saturday (Feb. 10).

On Friday, former Black Sabbath frontman Ozzy Osbourne also called out Kanye West on social media, saying that Ye had asked to sample a song but was “refused permission because he is an antisemite.” Osbourne said he used the sample anyway at a Vultures 1 listening event at Chicago’s United Center this week. “I want no association with this man!” the rocker wrote. Although Osbourne said online that West asked to sample “War Pigs,” the song he seems to have used at the event is “Iron Man.”

Bites bats head off on stage

Still comes out looking better than kanye

Parody and covers are fine but when you steal actual audio you really need permission or be prepared to pay in perpetuity for the theft. RIAA really needs to go after him for piracy.

Parody is fine. Covers are a legal grey area (in U.S. law anyway). You probably won't get in trouble if you're a act performing a cover of I Feel Love at a live event, but if you're going to sell a recording of the cover without a mechanical license, you could very well face legal trouble- even that is in a grey area because digital platforms like Apple Music automatically pay the publishers if you sell a cover through them and publishers seem satisfied with that arrangement. Even performing on a streaming platform like YouTube technically requires a synchronization license, although, again, YouTube often pays publishers a cut of advertising revenue.

As I said above, performing a cover live generally won't get you in trouble, but tribute bands are another story. If you want to do a Donna Summer tribute band and you don't get legal permission, your ass is going to get sued.