If presidential immunity is absolute..

cmeu@lemmy.world to No Stupid Questions@lemmy.world – 201 points –

Could Biden order Trump's execution and win the next election?

85

You are viewing a single comment

Wait, I've been out of the loop for a bit; is Trump actually saying that he should be immune to charges because he was the president??? How in the world could he think that would work?

Yes, his lawyers have argued that he could order the assassination of a political rival and be immune. And the conservatives judges agree.

That last part isn't a fact. We don't have a ruling and we don't know how they will vote.

(God knows how this court will vote but don't spread misinformation)

"The conservative justices don't immediately and vehemently disagree"

I think we can agree that this is a fact. And already troubling enough.

Would they agree if Biden used his absolute power to pass a federal law guaranteeing safe access to abortion?

You’ve been out of the loop for a while now then.

I honestly envy them.

Don't. It's people that are out of the loop (people that work too much, don't care, people with busy lives, etc) who are at risk of falling for Republican propaganda about how bad Biden is and how good Trump is.

An informed populace is always for the best. It's why Republicans attack education and freedom of information so hard.

Be thankful to be informed and thankful you can actually act on it. For now.

Yes, that is exactly what he is saying. Yes, it is completely absurd and would undermine the bedrock principles of our legal system. However, apparently somewhere between 3 and 6 members of the US Supreme Court may be seriously considering it.

(To be fair, he does claim that this absolute immunity would go away if half of the House and 2/3 of the Senate decided to impeach the President.)

Then again, with that same theory, he could just eliminate Congress altogether before the voting starts for impeachment. Or place specific justices on house arrest before they vote. Basically, the idiotic idea of a president not beholden to laws is mostly the same as a despotism if the "president" wishes it to be.

What do you mean how? He did a bunch of crimes and has not seen any jail time. It’s been working

Yep that's the argument. At the end of the day it's a stalling tactic to push the trial past election day.

Yes. But, just an FYI, that's not the actual reason they're trying to claim it in court. They know it will never succeed, they just want to use it to delay his election trial until after the election.