Is there any Lemmy app/client that allows you to comment from a different account?

HiramFromTheChi@lemmy.world to Fediverse@lemmy.world – 65 points –

I remember Slide for Reddit allowed you to choose who to comment as before doing so.

Does this exist for Lemmy yet?

38

In lifftoff it is hidden feature. Under three dots -> view on another instance
you can reply from another account

Can confirm, this works!

Bear in mind Liftoff is probably going to stop working with Lemmy 0.19 so don't get too attached to it 😢

Is the project actually dead or is this an assumption based on lack of recent updates? I'm using liftoff and have been wondering about its future.

A couple of people have tried to get in touch with the dev to no avail. It's already broken for users on the couple of servers that are using 0.19 so only a matter of time for the rest of us, it seems.

Thanks for the reply. Sucks to hear it since it's been the best app for me so far. Any app recommendations for a replacement?

There's a thread in !liftoff@lemmy.world where people are recommending their fave replacement but tbh pretty much every app gets at least one mention, which one is best probably depends on your priorities!

None of them really meet all my needs (neither did Liftoff, I had to combine it with Summit), so I'm trying to help out by testing !raccoonforlemmy@lemmy.world in the hopes that it could become my holy grail.

What are your needs?

  • Good support for multiple accounts
  • Easy on the eyes, which means among other stuff none of that forced solid black background stuff as it gives me a headache
  • Customisable text for similar reasons to the above
  • Easy to post & reply & generally interact with people (some apps make it real difficult to continue a convo from your inbox, for example)
  • Basic mod capabilities
  • Multi-communities are a big bonus (this is why I keep Summit installed)

Generally I prefer more features over slick looks which I think is where a lot of people go the other way. Probably depends if you post a lot or are more of a scroller. I currently have 11 apps installed so will just keep testing them all out until one wins, lol.

Personally I enjoy Jerboa

Tried Jerboa again recently. Didn't love it but I'll probably check it out again at some point.

It's definitely a bit rough around the edges but personally I like it more than most of the others I've tried

It's developed by the main Lemmy dev as far as I understand. Closest thing to an 'official' app we've got. But other apps just suit me better ATM. I'm still testing different apps now and then since the apps are still rapidly being developed and dying out. Settled on Liftoff initially, but I remember liking Thunder and so far Raccoon is looking promising.

I do want to branch out again trying other apps as Jerboa (while nice) I feel is lacking a bit

It's functional enough but kinda meh

I like the UI though

Yeah it seems a little spartan. But, it's probably going to be the most up-to-date whenever there is an update to Lemmy itself since it's the same dev.

2 more...
2 more...

I don't think there's been any confirmation but with a breaking update looming it's not looking promising.

2 more...
2 more...
2 more...
2 more...

Most apps support multi-account but I think what the OP is asking for is the ability to switch account just for replying on a post/comment and for that reply only or when composing a post in a community, while continuing to use the main account afterwards.

Boost for lemmy is what I use. Just add your accounts and then change the account.

Eternity does that too, when you click on the comment button you can change the account from within the comment

~~Sync ~~did support it, now you need to be in the account that you wanted to reply as before hand.

Play store link: Sync for Lemmy

Do you need to enable the setting anywhere? I'm not seeing it.

You need to be in the account you want to use before opening post.

Wait, it does? I remember Sync for Reddit did but I don't see it here.

You need to be in the account you want to use before opening post.

You are correct change who you are posting as at commenting time, is not a feature.

You mean the "attempt to load post from your instance" thing?

Summit lets you switch user from most pages, so I can switch user when reading these comments but not actually while typing the comment

Yeah, I mean changing accounts right before writing the comment would work. Doesn't need to be able to switch in the middle of writing the comment.