Elon Musk ‘Secretly’ Used Starlink To Foil A Ukrainian Attack On Russian Naval Fleet Over Fear Of Nuclear War: Report

Flying Squid@lemmy.world to politics @lemmy.world – 1670 points –
Elon Musk ‘Secretly’ Used Starlink To Foil A Ukrainian Attack On Russian Naval Fleet Over Fear Of Nuclear War: Report
mediaite.com

What an utter piece of shit.

445

You are viewing a single comment

Fucking charge him with something. This is insane... If it's not treason, it sure as hell is undermining the billions of dollars in aid were sending Ukraine. We've sent 76 billion dollars so far.

Yeah, if an unelected CEO can tell a democratically elected government what it can and can't do we're no better than medieval peasants who had to bow and scrape for the nobles' favor

we're no better than medieval peasants who had to bow and scrape for the nobles' favor

It's been like that for decades(centuries?). The rich do as they please and the rest of us are treated like livestock. It's impressive citizens don't revolt more than they do these days.

Vote with your wallet. If you hate him so much don’t buy anything from him. It’s a fair meritocracy, if you think you can run a better space satellite company you are welcome to try

You know at SpaceX and Tesla, there is a layer of management between Musk and the actual production team, that does nothing but run interference. Their job is to make sure the companies stay running and moving forward, DESPITE, what Musk says.

That sounds like it was made up by somebody who is jealous of his intelligence and leadership skills

I think it’s funny that Musk simps think peoppe are jealous when we criticize him. Honey, I wouldn’t trade places with Musk if you paid me. I already dealt with teenage insecurities, and I’d rather have average amounts of money and people who actually love me than a yawning void in my soul constantly sereking approval from adoring crowds. I want to be decent and useful to the world more than I want to be rich. And I’m not alone. You wanting to be Elon Musk doesn’t mean everyone does.

You people need to stop feeding the trolls. If you actually think this isn't a satirical account after reading the other shit he has posted, then you yourself are likely insane.

Stop wasting your time, the only way to make them go away is to ignore them.

Bold of you to assume I took the time to read the other stuff he posted. And ignoring trolls doesn’t actually do much to discourage them, ime. So I’ll keep doing as I please, thanks.

I refuse to believe that this post that was below like 30 other ones was the only one you read.

Yes, ignoring trolls is how you get rid of them, that is exactly how it works. You feed a wild bear, he will come back for more than the last time. Trolls are exactly the same way.

Well, you’re free to do you. However, in my experience, ignoring trolls rarely has an effect.

Ignoring a troll works because if you do not feed them, they will go on to find others that will.

I understand the theory, it’s just not my experience that it makes any difference in practice.

It's worked for me, but YMMV. The only cases it hasn't worked for me are ones who PM you.

“It’s a fair meritocracy…” I do not think those words mean what you think they mean.

1 more...
1 more...

Stop trying to tell a private citizen and businessman what he can and can’t do with his own business

He got to where he is with government funding.

Turn off the tap. Now.

First of all he got there by being the best businessman in the world, lots a hard work and plucky stick-to-it-ive-ness plus a keen eye for innovation. Think about this. If he hadn’t used his space satellites to stop the Ukies, Putin could have launched the Nukies! Basically he saved the planet and this is the thanks you give him. No good deed goes unpunished

Best business man in the world. Buys an unprofitable company for 40b, then runs it directly into the ground. Genius.

It’s part of a bigger strategy that you wouldn’t understand

Strategically losing billions, bold plan cotton

The troll account is annoying when you're crowding out other discussion.

I’m the only one bringing common sense to these discussions at all

He got where he is off the back of slavery in an emerald mine his father runs you twat

When you have a contract with the federal government it comes with stipulations. Don't "private citizen" this. It's not a mom and pop store.

But Starlink DIDN'T have a contract with the US government, DOD, or Ukraine government. That's the point. And they went ahead and used it for guided munitions.

Which is a violation of the terms of service and not what anyone at SpaceX had intended.

Problem is, that's exactly how they ended up being used!

You're tracking that Starlink sells service directly to the US military for activities that aren't exactly tickle parties right?

True, but didn't Starshield happen after this stuff? I guess I need to relook at the timeline. But as I remember things, he started tossing starlink access at Ukraine, tried to get DoD to pay, they chose not to. Then he started to these games, and after that DoD started paying up. Starshield was announced a little bit after that.

Where do you draw the line? Should he also be allowed to sell his services to Russia? Should private companies from the US be allowed to sell arms to Russia?

Never mind that. Let’s suppose he can sell his services to whomever he likes.

What about the privacy implications? How did he know that specific attack was planned? Can he just listen in on any communication going across Starlink? I don’t think anyone should be okay with that.

How did he know that specific attack was planned?

Ukraine asked him to extend Starlink coverage for the attack.

No conspiracy theory needed, they just told him.

Since he runs Starlink, he has a map of where every single Starlink receiver is located. Literally, a real time map with GPS coordinates.

Russia would kill to have that info.

However, musk also hack and jam proofed Starlink to help Ukraine too.

There's currently sanctions on buying or selling a lot of things from Russia aren't there?

The whole reason this happened is because he disabled Starlink satellites over Russia in order to help the Ukrainian war effort. He just refused to turn it on for a specific offensive operation in Crimea that Ukraine requested - claiming he wanted to avoid escalation. Him and the US government were in agreement during time. Remember the US did not want to give tanks and planes because of fear of escalation.

I don't mean to try and put a damper on the 5 minute hate session but I wish people would make an effort to try and understand what is happening before they make all sorts of wild conclusions and statements.

I'm not sure where the line is but expecting a private citizen to provide vital defense infrastructure to your foreign allies and continually act in your best interests is clearly past it.

The issue is removing infrastructure on your own personal whims when it goes against what your own tax payers are paying for, especially when they have funded your company / companies. It's obscene.

Except it wasn't "removed", he declined to "extend" it before getting paid by those tax payers.

Of course. That’s called capitalism and the free market. Don’t like it? Move to Venezuela

Nah, I'd rather attack the cancer that is capitalism at the source and work to rid the world of its scourge once and for all. Sorry you chose the loser's side.

7 more...
7 more...
7 more...

Why? I think capitalism’s a toxic system and he has no moral right to his wealth.

Exactly, you can't have your cake and eat it - if we want to live in a sane and moral world we shouldn't let private citizens own things that are important, especially not satellite infrastructure

"Citizen" is the critical word here

"Ukraine" telling a "US citizen" what to do, are the critical words here.

Hes a US Citizen undermining the US Government

Is he? Did the US Government issue an order to attack Russian assets? Even Russian assets on Ukrainian soil? Even to support any Ukrainian effort to attack Russian assets?

So far it's been a "we give Ukraine some stuff and intel, and let them do the fighting while keeping a semblance of plausible deniability".

Sounds more like a direct involvement in the attack, would've been undermining the US Government.

15 more...
16 more...