Game rule idea

Sibbo@sopuli.xyz to 196@lemmy.blahaj.zone – 982 points –
61

There is a YouTube series "Odd One Out" by Jubilee with that premise, not necessarily gay but other social groups as well. In one episode, there really were only Odds and no one how was what they pretended all to be

Started watching it based on your comment. Itโ€™s mid, but good enough to watch and can be funny. I am hoping it picks up a bit though.

This would be a nightmare because I have no idea what the signals look like.

The show would be very revealing as we'd learn what 12 men think the signals look like!

What signals?

Maybe the ones that ping on "gaydar"?

Had a girl one time tell me she has perfect gaydar. Asked her if I was and without skipping a beat she said โ€œyeah you areโ€โ€ฆ. Spoiler: Iโ€™m not.

FRIENDZONED

Luckily she was just a friend of mine who was already married. But her look when I said that Iโ€™m not was priceless.

So when one of them is voted off, does a screen plate report the exiled contestant is gay? Because if they're all typical straights and the comedy is based on them being at least a bit homophobic.

This reminds me of classic USMC gay chicken, which seems to be a conspiracy to turn all our fresh trained marines totally gay questioning.

If all the men are straight, the game will end after one week no matter who gets voted out (and everybody except the one guy who's worst at acting gay gets $1M).

I guess that's not a problem, as long as the folks making it are okay with it being a one-off special and not a series.

No, it ends when you're down to two people. That's ten people who have to be voted off, so ten weeks of TV.

Then you reveal the premise to the last two guys, and tell them that they have to roshambo for the prize money.

Once a week someone gets outvoted, until 2 are left, or the straight man is out

(emphasis added)

If they're all straight, then the straight man is necessarily voted out the first week.

I'm only getting into semantics because you are - that statement is singular and definite, therefore it can only be taken to have one of two meanings:

A) a given straight man is selected at the start, and once he is voted out it ends.

B) it ends once the final straight man is voted out, as at that point he would be the straight man. This can never occur as he would win by being the only one remaining, so there would be no vote for him to vote himself out.

If they're all straight without a single selection at the start, then there is not a definite straight man, and even if there is one selected at the start there's only a 1/12 chance he gets voted out first.

I mean, dude, obviously that's just the version of the rules that you're giving to the competitors.

Nah, let them play a game of chicken.

The one doing the most gay thing wins. See how far both of them would go.

Suddenly it just becomes "who'll make a gay porno for 7 figures?"

The answer is everyone.

1 more...

I would be voted out so fucking quick and Iโ€˜m proud of it.

Edit: Oh fuck my dumbass misread this and thought gay people would be voted out

The more time that passes between each repost is more time for the premise to be less "2005 dude-bros can't fathom being unmasculine for a second" and more "when did Troye Sivan write this?"

I feel like it would work better as a show with like 5 gay men. That way you get reaction shots of gay men judging straight men trying to act gay, and things actually progress romantically. I feel like anyone who thinks they are the one straight guy might just act like a sexually conservative gay man, the pressure will be on when people start talking about things getting more sexual.