The quote from Magritte there sums it up quite well.
This is not a pipe, it’s just a tribute.
Seems like the parsing of words at its worse. I'm okay with not knowing the referance.
It's a famous painting with the french phrase for "this is not a pipe" cropped off
Meme would've made more sense if they hadn't cropped it off, why did they do that?
Because it makes it into an in-joke for those of us who know what the text says
What's funny about this is their determination to violate the artists' intent for the sake of forced obfuscation, which results in the ostensible heightening of obscure knowledge for the benefit of those already possessing it.
I see nothing of value being created here. So, we're at a level slightly above Reddit right now. We did it, Lemmy!
The point was that it's not an actual pipe, but a representation of a pipe. Magritte liked being the best kind of correct.
The person who drew that pipe captioned it "This is not a pipe" in French.
For some reason it's a popular piece. I don't really like it because I prefer art to be aesthetically interesting rather than "any creative work that makes a statement."
Ahh I see. Seems like andy worhol level creativity. i never really understood why his stuff was considered art, but my brain glides over stuff better than gretzky's skates so I'm probably no judge.
I actually love the Dadaist movement, although this piece is not really my favorite. Truth be told, I don’t love the art of the Dadaist movement, so much as I love what it represented.
This piece is named “The treachery of images” but most people refer to it by ‘This is not a pipe’ because, well, that’s what’s written on it.
It’s basically an art shitpost. Of course it’s not a pipe. It’s a painting of a pipe.
But the Dadaist movement is basically all art shitposting. Dada is an utterance that roughly means “yeah, whatever” and came about as a form of protest art against the bourgeoisie, and their overly rigid definition of art after WW1. In that time it was common for the rich of various nations to embrace specific forms of art as an expression of nationalism.
Dadaists were like “fuck that, art is whatever the hell the artist says it is.” Because art for just the rich sucks, as does art that’s only in one format, and nationalism, too.
My favorite story is that Marcel Duchamp submitted “Fountain” a urinal that had been turned sideways and signed “R. Mutt” to an art show that ostensibly showed everything submitted to it, but the organizers hid his piece, and it’s rumored that they threw it away after taking a photo of it.
The treatment of the submission and mystery surrounding it brought about tremendous attention, furthering the Dadaist movement.
Dada imagery shitposting is nothing compared to Dada theater shitposting. Ever seen Ubu Roi? You'll probably wish you didn't.
On the other hand, I can't be too critical of Alfred Jarry. He used to walk around Paris with a lobster on a leash.
I never really understood why his stuff was considered art
Someone will be saying this looking at internet memes in a museum in 50 years, while everyone else will be acclaiming a portray of loss.
Alright I guess I'll be the first to admit: I don't get it.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Treachery_of_Images
The quote from Magritte there sums it up quite well.
This is not a pipe, it’s just a tribute.
Seems like the parsing of words at its worse. I'm okay with not knowing the referance.
It's a famous painting with the french phrase for "this is not a pipe" cropped off
Meme would've made more sense if they hadn't cropped it off, why did they do that?
Because it makes it into an in-joke for those of us who know what the text says
What's funny about this is their determination to violate the artists' intent for the sake of forced obfuscation, which results in the ostensible heightening of obscure knowledge for the benefit of those already possessing it.
I see nothing of value being created here. So, we're at a level slightly above Reddit right now. We did it, Lemmy!
And Dadaism was the movement.
This is not a comment.
This is not a reply.
That’s exactly why I refuse to respond to it.
It is.
And it is a representation of a comment.
I don't get it.
The point was that it's not an actual pipe, but a representation of a pipe. Magritte liked being the best kind of correct.
The person who drew that pipe captioned it "This is not a pipe" in French.
For some reason it's a popular piece. I don't really like it because I prefer art to be aesthetically interesting rather than "any creative work that makes a statement."
Ahh I see. Seems like andy worhol level creativity. i never really understood why his stuff was considered art, but my brain glides over stuff better than gretzky's skates so I'm probably no judge.
I actually love the Dadaist movement, although this piece is not really my favorite. Truth be told, I don’t love the art of the Dadaist movement, so much as I love what it represented.
This piece is named “The treachery of images” but most people refer to it by ‘This is not a pipe’ because, well, that’s what’s written on it.
It’s basically an art shitpost. Of course it’s not a pipe. It’s a painting of a pipe.
But the Dadaist movement is basically all art shitposting. Dada is an utterance that roughly means “yeah, whatever” and came about as a form of protest art against the bourgeoisie, and their overly rigid definition of art after WW1. In that time it was common for the rich of various nations to embrace specific forms of art as an expression of nationalism.
Dadaists were like “fuck that, art is whatever the hell the artist says it is.” Because art for just the rich sucks, as does art that’s only in one format, and nationalism, too.
My favorite story is that Marcel Duchamp submitted “Fountain” a urinal that had been turned sideways and signed “R. Mutt” to an art show that ostensibly showed everything submitted to it, but the organizers hid his piece, and it’s rumored that they threw it away after taking a photo of it.
The treatment of the submission and mystery surrounding it brought about tremendous attention, furthering the Dadaist movement.
Dada imagery shitposting is nothing compared to Dada theater shitposting. Ever seen Ubu Roi? You'll probably wish you didn't.
On the other hand, I can't be too critical of Alfred Jarry. He used to walk around Paris with a lobster on a leash.
Someone will be saying this looking at internet memes in a museum in 50 years, while everyone else will be acclaiming a portray of loss.
Ceci n'est pas une pipe
Non, c'est une pipe!
https://youtu.be/6lHgbbM9pu4
Here is an alternative Piped link(s):
https://piped.video/6lHgbbM9pu4
Piped is a privacy-respecting open-source alternative frontend to YouTube.
I'm open-source; check me out at GitHub.
Take it to the next level and poison the image so that AIs don't think it's even a representation of a pipe
This is not a painting
ĉi tio ne estas pipo
*Pipeaux
Sed mi vidas pipon‽
ne, vi ne
I mean, it's not the painting my Magritte, so who cares?
Now where could my pipe be?
Ah! A person of culture I see!
See also dada
- FlyingSquid
|
C'est une pipe.
(╯°□°）╯︵ ┻━┻
I always thought it was a pie (as in the food)
That's not a knife...
Can you put tobacco in it? Then you will be lying!
Do you smoke Paul?
Galaxy brain dada jokes here
Eso no es un chiste.
I'd post the dick pipe by the same artist, but that'd be pornographic.
POST THE DICK PIPE HOBBIT FOOT
DEWWW EEEEETTTT
A was a as.
abZZ as zzAs A ` a b. AaAaVavva@av1. Aa``azas1. asas 9z
Aaaabaaz ba Azbza/**AZazB`z zB azAszzZzv BE AZb