Its a conspiracy by Big Red to profit from infringing on Purple's intellectual property. All the other primary colours are in cahoots. Its time to take down their shadowy cabal.
it was named before purple was invented
Ok, so we can never ever change the name.
So says Robin Red Breast, the bird with orange belly feathers
Big Blue is doing the same thing with blue grapes. Poor purple...
Not my cleanest work but it's fine if you don't look too close
:::
Looks great mate, no one would notice if they don't know.
Also I think the template in itself is funny in an anti joke kind of way where you expect him to be protesting something but then he's just holding up an empty piece of cardboard really passionately lol.
They played us for absolute fools...
With this knowledge, we can't left him alive.
- The onion industry, probably.
Anthocyanins
Tor?
I can. Easily. But then, I have color perception deficiency. But do not luck ability to argue as compensation.
They can be purplish in some growth stages but on the whole they are a deep red, a crimson. Unless my eyes are just broken.
None of those are red. They're all close to red, but none of them are actually red.
Anthocyanins are responsible for the color and they act as a pH indicator, changing color from bright red in acid to bright blue in basic solutions. Soil acidity could have an impact on their color at harvest, but it also really depends on how you use them. If you put them raw in a salad, they'll probably turn quite red regardless, but it's also quite common to find them as a purple color.
Purple isn't a real color. Red + Blue on the color spectrum is Green.
Red + blue(indigo) = a color not on the chart? but in between the two colors is clearly green!
We perceive purple as an activation of Red and Blue cones in our eyes... The color itself actually doesn't exist as a discrete wavelength and is a collective hallucination of sorts.
Violet and Purple are indeed not the same thing. Purple exists in that we perceive it... that's not what I'm arguing against. It's just that it's not a "real" color. It's only because of this "mass hallucination" of sorts that we're okay just accepting that it must be a color when it isn't representable as a single spectrum color like every other color. It is purple... but purple isn't a real color, it's effectively just shorthand for saying that this color is both blue and red. It's just you being human.
Brown has the same problem in that it's just dark orange (from the light spectrum perspective). It turns out that brightness context matters to us, so we choose brown to represent a large swath of that.
I have a shorthand for “only real in the context that it’s real for humans”… hint, it has four letters and starts with “real”.
:) interesting info!
Just because violet light triggers both red and blue receptors in our eyes, that doesn't mean there is only discrete red and blue light hitting them. It's just that light with 380nm to 450nm wavelength triggers both typed of receptors. So there is violet light.
violet IS a discrete wavelength. Purple is not.
In short: Purple doesn't have it's own wavelength. Neither does white, black and the entire gray-scale or any mixing of any colour with the gray-scale and probably more. They're called non spectral colours.
It might be easier to understand when considering other types of waves. At least it is for me. A simple sound can also be described as a wave with a frequency, but if we play two sounds at the same time, we can't say that the sum of the waves has any specific frequency. The frequencies don't add up or multiply or mix as average. The combined sound can only be described as the addition of two frequencies.
In musical terms, purple is not a note, but instead a chord or interval. Red and blue can be individual notes, or they can be mixed as intervals. White is noise and black is silence.
You ARE the color
You're the only color I need
Umm...
Yeah, that doesn't mean it isn't a "real" color.
Literally does... There's a number of colors that we perceive that are fictitious. This is well known in color theory. https://grantsonnex.com/why-purple-doesnt-exist/ Don't believe me? That's fine. Listen to an actual artist who's whole job it is to understand colors. There is no "purple" on the light spectrum. And if you're the type to say violet=purple... then here you go! https://jakubmarian.com/difference-between-violet-and-purple/
If we cannot define a color by a wavelength... then it's a color we have to define by how it's perceived. That's not a "true" or "real" color. That doesn't mean it doesn't exist or cannot be perceived, but that it only exists because we perceive it and wouldn't otherwise.
"Brown" is also the same problem. Brown only exists in the context of light and darkness. You cannot just produce "Brown" light. You can produce vary levels of "Dark" orange... and in the context of a dark or light background you'll either see it as orange or brown.
Since you don't know how to read links. here you go specifically broken out of the paragraph for you to click. Or if you need more because you're "Special"?
Same with red cabbages.
Its a conspiracy by Big Red to profit from infringing on Purple's intellectual property. All the other primary colours are in cahoots. Its time to take down their shadowy cabal.
it was named before purple was invented
Ok, so we can never ever change the name.
So says Robin Red Breast, the bird with orange belly feathers
Big Blue is doing the same thing with blue grapes. Poor purple...
WTF are blue grapes?!?!
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bangalore_Blue
The chewing gum company is behind this?!?
There was no word for purple back then.
And yet they had purple onions. Curious.
Damn it Ben crawl back in the hole
It was taken from us by the Kaiser.
So I tied a red onion to my belt, which was the style at the time...
Gimme 5 bees for a quarter you'd say.
The future is now old man. Free the onion
Until you cook them. Then they’re purple-ly clear.
or you cook them with a base, like baking soda, then they turn green
Is this that "alchemy" thing I've heard so much about?
Or soak them in vinegar and they turn pink and make a delicious sandwich topping.
Atomic Purple
SF had a purple onion?!
Also:
Apparently “some mainland European countries” know their colors.
I like this. I think we're really getting into the nitty gritty of it now
This comment chain reads like the Magneto "no the real Purple Onion" meme.
::: spoiler Template
Not my cleanest work but it's fine if you don't look too close :::
Looks great mate, no one would notice if they don't know.
Also I think the template in itself is funny in an anti joke kind of way where you expect him to be protesting something but then he's just holding up an empty piece of cardboard really passionately lol.
They played us for absolute fools...
With this knowledge, we can't left him alive.
- The onion industry, probably.
Anthocyanins
Tor?
I can. Easily. But then, I have color perception deficiency. But do not luck ability to argue as compensation.
They can be purplish in some growth stages but on the whole they are a deep red, a crimson. Unless my eyes are just broken.
https://duckduckgo.com/?kp=-2&q=red+onion&iax=images&ia=images
About half of the pictures I see are Purple.
None of those are red. They're all close to red, but none of them are actually red.
Anthocyanins are responsible for the color and they act as a pH indicator, changing color from bright red in acid to bright blue in basic solutions. Soil acidity could have an impact on their color at harvest, but it also really depends on how you use them. If you put them raw in a salad, they'll probably turn quite red regardless, but it's also quite common to find them as a purple color.
Purple isn't a real color. Red + Blue on the color spectrum is Green.
Explain. I'm too high to understand this.
Just look at the spectrum chart here. https://www.thoughtco.com/the-visible-light-spectrum-2699036
Red + green = yellow...
Green + blue = cyan...
Red + Yellow = Orange...
Red + blue(indigo) = a color not on the chart? but in between the two colors is clearly green!
We perceive purple as an activation of Red and Blue cones in our eyes... The color itself actually doesn't exist as a discrete wavelength and is a collective hallucination of sorts.
Edit: Also... Brown isn't a color. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wh4aWZRtTwU (whoops, wrong link originally, fixed now.)
Fine do you want to call it a violet onion then? They are basically the exact same damn thing and violet is a wavelength
https://jakubmarian.com/difference-between-violet-and-purple/
Violet and Purple are indeed not the same thing. Purple exists in that we perceive it... that's not what I'm arguing against. It's just that it's not a "real" color. It's only because of this "mass hallucination" of sorts that we're okay just accepting that it must be a color when it isn't representable as a single spectrum color like every other color. It is purple... but purple isn't a real color, it's effectively just shorthand for saying that this color is both blue and red. It's just you being human.
Brown has the same problem in that it's just dark orange (from the light spectrum perspective). It turns out that brightness context matters to us, so we choose brown to represent a large swath of that.
I have a shorthand for “only real in the context that it’s real for humans”… hint, it has four letters and starts with “real”.
:) interesting info!
Just because violet light triggers both red and blue receptors in our eyes, that doesn't mean there is only discrete red and blue light hitting them. It's just that light with 380nm to 450nm wavelength triggers both typed of receptors. So there is violet light.
violet IS a discrete wavelength. Purple is not.
In short: Purple doesn't have it's own wavelength. Neither does white, black and the entire gray-scale or any mixing of any colour with the gray-scale and probably more. They're called non spectral colours.
It might be easier to understand when considering other types of waves. At least it is for me. A simple sound can also be described as a wave with a frequency, but if we play two sounds at the same time, we can't say that the sum of the waves has any specific frequency. The frequencies don't add up or multiply or mix as average. The combined sound can only be described as the addition of two frequencies.
In musical terms, purple is not a note, but instead a chord or interval. Red and blue can be individual notes, or they can be mixed as intervals. White is noise and black is silence.
You ARE the color
You're the only color I need
Umm...
Yeah, that doesn't mean it isn't a "real" color.
Literally does... There's a number of colors that we perceive that are fictitious. This is well known in color theory. https://grantsonnex.com/why-purple-doesnt-exist/ Don't believe me? That's fine. Listen to an actual artist who's whole job it is to understand colors. There is no "purple" on the light spectrum. And if you're the type to say violet=purple... then here you go! https://jakubmarian.com/difference-between-violet-and-purple/
If we cannot define a color by a wavelength... then it's a color we have to define by how it's perceived. That's not a "true" or "real" color. That doesn't mean it doesn't exist or cannot be perceived, but that it only exists because we perceive it and wouldn't otherwise.
"Brown" is also the same problem. Brown only exists in the context of light and darkness. You cannot just produce "Brown" light. You can produce vary levels of "Dark" orange... and in the context of a dark or light background you'll either see it as orange or brown.
Violet is purple.
https://jakubmarian.com/difference-between-violet-and-purple/
Since you don't know how to read links. here you go specifically broken out of the paragraph for you to click. Or if you need more because you're "Special"?
https://www.oleanderstudios.com/difference-between-violet-and-purple/
https://acrylicpaintingschool.com/violet-vs-purple/
https://www.colorwithleo.com/whats-the-difference-between-violet-and-purple/
https://byjus.com/physics/difference-between-violet-and-purple/
Do I have to keep going?
No need to be such an asshole about it. Keep that on reddit.
And just like reddit... they could have actually read the post. But they didn't. So it looks like we're all redditors here.
Interesting... So they're two different colors right?
So purple is a color.
I think it's better to make the distinction between color and light wavelenght instead of just saying purple isn't real.
In my native language it's actually called purple onion.
And gross. Petition to replace all onions with their vastly superior cousins, the shallot.
This comment is clearly racist towards the whole of Eastern Europe. I’m reporting it right away.
But I love borscht!
But pickled red onions are the shit.
Red onion cult rise up.
I feel sorry for you.
Pickled anything is shit. That disgusting vinegar stench makes me retch.
They also taste nasty because they're onions.
How dare???? 😠
muriatic acid tastes less like acid than onions.
Is that bad? Acidic is a staple flavor archetype in food all over the world. I remember not liking onions as a child... Then I realized I was wrong.
Yeah I've basically retried every food I was picky about as a child.
Turns out I like all sorts of stuff if it's cooked right!
Acid actually tastes sour.
Fun fact! Acid tastes sour because that's what sour is