Current state of Reddit

Scrubbles@poptalk.scrubbles.tech to Mildly Infuriating@lemmy.world – 658 points –

My friend sent me this, the current state of Reddit. (I left during the app issue and haven't looked back)

183

Used to browse Reddit daily. Once Reddit is Fun closed, I only go on to search for an answer.

Now it is Lemmy daily.

The way Spez and the admins treated Apollo's dev was more than enough for me to leave Reddit, and that's before the shit he said about the vulnerable users of his site (essentially seeing them as dollar signs - I know CEOs are scummy but holy fuck).

whats this about the vulnerable users?

A lot of third party integrations to improve accessibility for visually or physically impaired users were caught up in the restrictions designed to destroy RIF Apollo etc. Spez vaguely said reddit would fix that, but it basically just resulted in improvements to base reddit for those users thrown into the bottom of a low priority dev list never to see the light of day.

Oh I knew about that. With the way he said that I figured there was a specific quote that he said something about calling the user base vulnerable.

"There's a lot of stuff on the site that you'd only ever say in therapy, or AA, or never at all ... But we don't need to give all of that value to some of the largest companies in the world for free."

Open Lemmy, nothing new, close Lemmy. Open Lemmy again to check if something new. Nothing new.

That's the idea. Helps you not become a dopamine addicted mess.

Same for me. Once RIF died my time with Reddit died as well. But i really try not tongo back, but sometimes some answers are only easily found there.

I somehow was banned for “hate”. I literally have 0 idea what I could have possibly said. I appealed, of course nobody actually reads those and I am still perma banned. 10 years of history. Oh well. To Lemmy it is.

Oh I remember saying something along the lines of Ron Desantis was a dirty diaper and should be thrown out in the trash on a conservative Reddit.

The mods tried to have me banned over it and said I was harassing them. Unbelievable when all they did was talk smack about everyone. I learned when Reddit suspended my account over mods being butthurt that it was going down the drain.

Same but with Sync for Reddit instead, now I use Sync for Lemmy.

This. There’s a handful of subreddits that aren’t on Lemmy that I miss but generally speaking I’ve got everything I need on Lemmy. I’m also a lot more engaged here.

And once I can figure out a better wildcare search for the fediverse, I won't visit Reddit at all!

I used to check Reddit pretty often, at least once every other day. Now I've found I use Lemmy rarely. I use Reddit more often still but that's just to look up questions or get help with some issue. I mostly just use Discord now, and am only checking here because it's down.

u/K4sum11 on Reddit if you're curious

7 more...

That’ll be $49.99, pal.

Don't call me pal. But you know what friend? I think it would be hilarious if this image started getting used ironically.

Which reddit probably won't give any to the creator

You mean the commentor? Or thread creator? Nothing for anyone creating the content that warranted the upvote?

Think just who it's given too not any other part. You've thought this out more than reddit did

Actually, they will, a part at least

Only if the person has received a total of 10 special arrows recently, or something.

Curiously enough, 99% of awards go to people ineligible for a share of the money.

Sounds like buying expensive-but-worthless loot boxes to send as gifts

I'd rather receive a loot box than a $30 special reddit png that I don't even get anything for.

I guarantee the vast majority of gold rewards will be going straight into Reddit's pocket. The contrived requirements to get a payout are designed to keep as much of it for themselves as they can, while still saying it's "possible" for users to get some of the money for themselves.

I hope people start posting pictures like this instead of paying for them

I love the vibrant colours of that vomit.

I was just thinking the same thing. More than the usual amount of love went into that one, and most people probably wouldn't even stop to notice. The subtle fade-out at the top. That is some pleasing vomit.

Look at that subtle off-green gradient. The tasteful thickness of it… Oh my god, it even has ornaments...

I had to pause for a second. Most high def emoji I've ever seen. Can't believe I just typed that.

... and I am starting to see user agent and VPN blocks now just within the last few days... It's officially over, so glad to be here. Been in the fediverse since the API shutdown. Bouncing between instances. First post on this one! Absolutely no regrets.

Yeah I read they tried to play that off as an accident. You don't "accidentally" block VPN users. That just doesn't accidentally happen. They're obviously attempting to do it, just waiting to deploy it. The anonymous social network sure does seem like they want you to not be anonymous.

Is that what happened? I occasionally check reddit at work since it's unfortunately still one of the better places for actual answers to things, and in the last few days I've needed to use old.reddit.com to get around getting blocked. VPN block explains a lot.

It's not confirmed what happened internally, but it was talked about a lot here for a while. Apparently VPN users were unable to access it and Reddit admins said that it was all accidental. It has just happened multiple times. Only for VPN users.

Yeah happening to mullvad vpn users for sure.

But it's not like they would think they could block vpn users and no one would notice and complain. The fact that they fixed it means the nefarious explanation doesn't pass the sniff test.

My guess is that it's something like that in the process of trying to stop scraping, their filter was cast too wide and it snagged more VPN users than it meant to.

I am constantly amazed that anyone is still using that corporate dumpster fire of a website

"See you next week," one user smugly commented to me on my way out.

I haven't been back, and I haven't missed it.

The overwhelming smugness was the very thing that finally got me to leave lol

To be honest, they were right as often as they were wrong. Plenty of folks who proclaimed they’d never return to Reddit returned within the month. Some of the most outspoken were the quickest. I find the mods who returned particularly giggle-worthy.

Lol I left with the APIcalypse, and I was an official app user, no regrets and never looked back. Why would anyone go to that shithole when you have the fediverse?

The smaller subs (such as for specific hobbies) do not have the same momentum here on Lemmy. That's probably why.

Im sure Id have gotten said responses too, but ai kinda got my account suspended shortly before. The closest ive gotten on lemmy is that ive had some comments removed for valid reasons, and then their the fact that I think one of the world news mods has a grudge against me or their tools blanket remove comments.

Oh yeah I got IP banned for "abusing the report button" by reporting a literal call for violence against trans people. I had to use a VPN to browse that shitty site. In retrospect, I don't know why I bothered.

I also got an IP ban alongside it, mind you I was proposing drowning the leaders of the UAE and Saudia Arabia. I was on NCD so I figured no one would care enough to report it, mind you my two previous strikes were from 2016, so who fucken knows what I said then.

I used to check in on againsthatesubs and report shitty content and new (usu replacement) hate subs that popped up. Admin barely cared about that shit

Yeah, I was on that sub as well, occasionally. I respect Bardfinn, the lead mod of AHS, but they used to tell me that accounts were restored on appeal if moderators retaliated by reporting users for "abusing the report button," but my appeal was never accepted, and it was a clear instance of mod retaliation. I finally shared that experience when I was on my way out of the site for good.

God... I can barely remember the time before the top comment threads of every goddamned post were always lazy strings of circle-jerky jokes that you could predict before even clicking into the thread.

I could barely remember too, then I took an arrow to the knee!

Something something narwhal bacon

I too choose this narwhal's dead bacon

Wow, epic! I rate this comment 5/7 with rice! You've won the internet for today, my friend! I'll pet my heckin chonky pupperino in your honor! You're breathtaking!

This is better than that time my arms were broken and my mom took care of me (don't worry, we're not from Alabama! LOL 😂)

Don't you love it when they're not even made by humans, but it's just bots copying the top comment from the last time it got posted

I was hoping when I came over here it would be more like the good old days of reddit. And i think it is, but barely. Plenty of the low quality shit made the jump as well.

Just look at this thread. Sort by top. The top post is circle jerking about people left reddit for here. The next top post is a vomiting emoji. A fucking emoji. I haven't even been here that long and the comments in this thread were predictable in the same exact way.

I feel like that's more of the state of how we communicate with eachother. Verbal communication is increasingly low effort and low quality just like any social media platforms I've been on. The only exception is hyper niche communities who's main focus is on the actual INFORMATION. Ultimately, low importance/helpful post are going to have low importance/helpful responses.

ngl I haven't been back to reddit since the exodus, but my youtube watching has gone up waaay too high.

Honestly, same. Between the algorithm throwing wild but entertaining YouTube shorts and me starting to watch longer more educational content, I find myself going on the reddit mobile site very rarely.

I'm in this exact same boat and I don't love it. I don't know if my ADHD is acting up or if YouTube has made my productivity take a nosedive (got fired a month ago due to it), but I can't help myself from watching hours of YouTube a day. I feel like reddit was at least easier to disengage from in order to be productive.

I can't even open reddit on a phone nowadays, cause my preferred sub have 18+ posts and reddit don't let you access that if you not logged in. Also, there a notification, that I need to use shitty official mobile app. Also, there notification to login via google. Also, there a notification... Nope, I not using this shit ever again.

Firefox mobile now has a full suite of extensions, including old reddit redirect to bypass all that bs. It's the only way I access reddit anymore for answers/the last few niche communities that haven't been built up on lemmy yet.

I thought about doing that but then I decided that I don't care about the opinions of people who somehow put up with all that shit

For the occasional time where I’m troubleshooting something and Reddit has the only solution on an “unmoderated sub” or one with 18+ posts, I just change the “www” in the URL to “old”, and get the old, non mobile friendly UI. It lets you bypass the other app popups, etc. Sometimes when you go into a post you’re back in the new UI, and might get another pop up, but backing out or changing the url to “old” usually solves it in my experience.

On another topic, what kind of complete nonsense is that comment section?

It reads like if my phone's autocomplete decided to go haywire one day and start spitting out random associated phrases: "Pablo Escobar... Colombian Drug Lord... District of Columbia...hungry hungry hippo..."

I don't even know which is worse, that these are all bots, or there are actually multiple people who thinks posting these in public is a good idea.

Pablo Escobar lived in Columbia and owned hippos.

Just because you don't get a joke doesn't mean it was written by a bot, you goon.

edit - I just realized that I called esteemed character performer Margot Robbie a goon. Many apologies. I respect your dedication to the craft.

I get all the references, but making a chain of references without any jokes isn't exactly funny.

Meta comedy is overused to the degree that it is difficult to do it well.

Not all of us are blessed with the incredible talent of the writers of the nine-time Golden Globe-nominated motion picture Barbie, two-time Critic's Choice Movie Award-winning actor Margot Robbie.

I think it looks like AI bots talking to each other.

Doesn't it feel weird that people feel guilty when being mean to you only because you are famous? You probably also have more anominous accounts so I wonder, how different does the internet feel as Margot Robbie and Jane Doe?

Doesn’t it feel weird that people feel guilty when being mean to you only because you are famous?

No, because there are plenty more people in life who won't feel guilty about being mean to you at all. It's more stressful in the days knowing a Twitter mob is ready to "slam" you for every little thing you say or do in life 24/7.

Besides, it's not like anything I say here can be tied back to me anyways. Why do you think I refuse to get verified?

You probably also have more anominous accounts

Ugh... That Letterboxd account...

No, because there are plenty more people in life who won't feel guilty about being mean to you at all. It's more stressful in the days knowing a Twitter mob is ready to "slam" you for every little thing you say or do in life 24/7.

Really understandable. Haters will always be a louder minority and when you have 9 positive comments and a single negative one, the negative one will stick out.

Besides, it's not like anything I say here can be tied back to me anyways. Why do you think I refuse to get verified?

That is probably the smart move. I have a unbsession with celebrities and such and when I hear people obsessing over every single detail of their lives, I feel sorry for the celebrities. If a single mishap gets blown up and reported of my life, I don't think I would handle. It feels like people enjoy the story of the mental degradation of celebrity X. It is disheartening.

That Letterboxd account I wasn't aware of this and it is one of those things where I don't want to click the articles explaing it. I personally have ADHD and if I was watched like that 24/7, I would slip up. Furthermore, all my social media accounts use the same name so it can easily be tracked, luckily no one cares.

Any how, good luck with it all. Sorry for my short sighted thought and thanks for explaining. Remember that most people see you in a really great way. These people just aren't the loudest.

Besides, it's not like anything I say here can be tied back to me anyways. Why do you think I refuse to get verified?

I wouldn't be so sure about that. On one hand, I totally don't believe you're the real Margot Robbie, so you do have plausable deniability, but if anyone gains access to your server either being the owner of it, hacking it, or having a warrant, it might be trivial to connect you to your account with your IP if you aren't using a VPN or Tor. Not that you'd likely be in that situation, but it is good to be aware of.

He lived in Colombia*, which I assume is how D.C. snuck into the comments. Took me a sec to follow that jump.

Yes. The DC in Washington DC stands for District of Columbia.

I just realized that I called esteemed character performer Margot Robbie a goon. Many apologies.

What's wrong with her posting on Something Awful?!

I just realized that I called esteemed character performer Margot Robbie a goon. Many apologies. I respect your dedication to the craft.

You should do an AMA. How did it feel being touched by god?

Now you should do an AMA too!

alright, be cool be cool be cool, it's just Margot Robbie.

Yeah I could totally do those one of AMA dooda thingies.

what the fuck was that abomination of a sentence? Okay okay okay, let's just try to smooth our way out of it.

Bye

Lmao they removed their somewhat unique award system with charm and replaced it with colored arrows

Audacity aside, wtf is the difference between the $1.99 and 3.99 gold???

One flat and the other is 3D

$2 is flat (apart from its rounded edges). $4 rises to a raised ridge in a line down the middle.

How much the “designer” moved the Inner Bevel slider to the right.

Afaik, it's multiples. So it goes 2 gold, 3 gold, 5 gold, etc. This means nothing to the vast majority of users, but a tiny minority may possibly get some of that money passed onto them if they fulfill Reddit's myriad of requirements to be part of the "Contributor Program" .

1 more...

Fifty bucks? Are the bits made of gold?

It's only there to make the other ones look cheap.

It didn't succeed.

Not for us but definitely for others. This kind of scale up pricing is all the rage because it works so well. Either some sucker buys the top thing as a flex or someone sees the $1 as a discount. Either purchase is a win. And us not buying it would be true at almost any price point so no loss of sale there.

Are reddit paying contributors, moderators or people creating posts¿? If no then how are they claiming that buying a golden upvote supports contributors

About 3 months ago? They killed off the old award system. Gold, platinum, ternium , and the 100 other things you could add to posts or comments with reddit coins were Thanos snapped out of existence.

Now theres golden up votes where somehow if I spend real money and give something a golden upvote, the writer could receive real money (only for some countries). Don't know all the details as I figured I wouldn't be receiving any and wasn't going to be giving any.

Very good point!

I am not a lawyer but isn't this something that is technically illegal? Or perhaps not, do donations need to be truthful in plain terms of how the funds are used ?

The only way I can see donating to reddit could be argued as helping/supporting contrubiters by having the platform and audience available.

do donations need to be truthful in plain terms of how the funds are used ?

I think in 2023 parlance the claim is probably plain enough to be "truthful".

Giving gold supports the contributors you love

It's pretty well established that receiving gold on reddit is perks like... a gold star or something, rather than actual real gold.

Hopefully the fact that they felt the need to do this means they're doing badly financially (and hopefully this doesn't help with that)

These arrows look like they were AI generated. "Make the arrow look more golden"

Now says it's more bots than humans, only small subs have more real humans IMO.

Very MTX-heavy mobile game aesthetic.

LMAO, imagine paying someone for content and then having a Reddit bot (or human) to copy it here for Lemmy.

Is this the new NFT lol?

This has gotta be the stupidest (and honestly ugliest) alternative to Reddit awards.

Thanks for the crudely gold-colored-brass up vote, kind stranger.

This entire screenshot looks horrible.

Giving Gold supports the contributors you love

Is... is this implying the person who got gilded gets a cut? Huh?

Yes

Interesting how they never say how much real money gold and upvotes are worth to these contributors

Well... nothing to real contributers. . The threshold is 10 golden upvotes. So only people who give themselves 10 golden upvotes can become eligible. No sane user would upvote someone who isn't allready eligible, because that money would literally be throwing money in the trash. Only circle jerking upvote bots and "companies" will get money.

Is it somewhere mentioned how to see, if someone is eligible? Or even if that is possible at all?

Or they funnel it all to GallowBoob or whoever his replacement is.

I've never had so much irrational hate for an online person than I did for that guy.

Man I totally forgot about that guy. I’ve had him blocked for ages.

r/todayilearned

Well, today you learned that this is the current state of Reddit.

Has no one here heard of redreader

Its still up due to an exemption iirc

QuantumBadger's RedReader for Android was the way I used Reddit for 6 years because the official app was hot trash and it still is shit.

I still stopped using Reddit entirely after July, because it that site sucks donkey balls. Lemmy all the way, baby.

Don't forget the fact that Redditcorp was treating RedReader along with the rest of the app developers with a "put up or shut up" attitude, despite them eventually caving and providing an exception from the blackout. There are still some good communities there I'm sure, but the site as a whole has lost my trust, so they don't get my contributions anymore.

When I need something, I go through my self-hosted libreddit instance.

I've also set up autoforwarding in case I accidentally click a Reddit link in the wild.

Re-dreader? What a strange name.

I too dread going back to that site.

I thought Reddit killed off gold earlier this year?

That was old gold. This is NEW gold. You can tell the difference by how much more NEW this NEW gold is.

And they killed the original gold years ago when they added platinum which turned into the orgy of trophies

This is why I only bother with latinum, gold is worthless.

Well you've still got the press the latinum in something, so that's at one use

I wonder how much gold it takes to stabilize latinum. I hope not much otherwise ferengi better've had some reinforced pockets for all the weight

It would be great if Lemmy's devs implemented loosely based (for fair use) copies of these and gave them for free :)

(yoinked from elsewhere in this comment section)

If you use the official app that's on you.

There's no other apps anymore. Which of course is the whole point.

Of course there are. I'm still using Infinity.

If you think you are using a third party app then you are even more stupid than you appear. All the third party apps are now controlled by Reddit which means they're essentially first party apps for all intents and purposes.

Good luck with that. Let me know when it inevitably leaks all your data

Possibly the most clueless comment I've ever read.

Really still going to tell me that you have access to a first party app that isn't controlled by Reddit?

Bearing in mind of course that I cannot be possibly held responsible for doing your thinking for you

By the looks of it you haven't ever done any thinking for anyone.

"You people who use the Reddit app that Reddit recommends you use after shutting down almost every other app that you can use to check Reddit? You people are idiots!"

You whiners are funny. Circlejerk just as bad as Reddit but think you're different.

Yeah but I'm not out here paying $50 to put some pixels on someone else's post. Cry more